This post will focus on the Alaska Senate contest, where preferential voting is used. Also: the Republican gerrymanders that backfired, spectacularly so in North Carolina.
Live Commentary
7:11pm Tuesday With 98% now counted, Peltola leads Sullivan by 50.0-45.9 on primary votes, but she’s just below a majority of the vote. It’s a bit silly that much of the US media still hasn’t called this race. Preferences will be distributed on Thursday AEDT.
3:49pm Amid the disastrous election for Republicans, they’ve made one House gain. In Maine’s rural second district, conservative Democrat Jared Golden retired, and the Republican nominee was a former Maine governor, Paul LePage. LePage defeated a left-wing Democrat by 50.8-49.2 after preferences.
3:28pm Another 4,200 votes have been counted in Alaska, boosting Peltola’s primary vote to 49.9% with 97% in.
9:38am Sunday (Two paragraph entry) In comments there’s a link to the preliminary preference count. This count doesn’t yet include all primary votes, so Peltola is 0.2 points below her current primary of 49.8%. After preferences, she beats Sullivan by 51.5-48.5, which can be projected to 51.7-48.3 on current primary votes.
For Alaska’s only House seat, Rep Begich is beating an independent by 51.7-48.3. For the governor, the Dem is winning by 57-43. There was also a referendum proposing to scrap preferential voting in Alaska, but this has been defeated by 53.5-46.5.
4:50pm Peltola will win the Alaska Senate contest, taking Democrats to a 56-44 Senate majority. With over 95% counted, she now has 49.8%, with Republican Sullivan on 46.1%. That’s close enough to the 50% + 1 that she needs to win, and she’ll cross that line on exhaust and leakage. Remaining votes are likely to be pro-Peltola. This will be Democrats’ ninth Senate gain, seven in states Trump won by double-digit margins in 2024.
Guest post by Adrian Beaumont, who joins us from time to time to provide commentary on elections internationally. Adrian is a paid election analyst for The Conversation. His work for The Conversation can be found here.
Ten days since the November 3 US mid-term elections, Democrats have won the federal Senate by 55-44 over Republicans with one contest still unresolved. Alaska uses preferential voting. With 88% counted, Democrat Mary Peltola has 49.1%, Republican incumbent Dan Sullivan 46.8%, a minor Republican 2.2% and another Dan Sullivan 1.6%.
Unlike Australian elections, there’s no indicative two-candidate count. If no candidate wins a majority of the primary vote, the tabulation of preferential votes occurs next Thursday AEDT. The large majority of the outstanding votes are in legislative districts that Peltola won, so her vote share should increase in later counting. But preferences from the minor Republican and the second Sullivan are likely to favour Sullivan.
Senators have six-year terms with one-third up for election every two years. Democrats who gained seats won’t be up for re-election until 2032, except in Ohio which was a special election. Winning the Senate by 56-44 would make it harder for Republicans to regain the Senate majority before 2032. If a Democrat wins the 2028 presidential election, Democrats would be able to get a filibuster-proof 60-vote Senate majority with a four-seat net gain.
On Thursday AEDT, the Mississippi Senate contest was called for Democrat Scott Colom, who defeated Republican incumbent Cindy Hyde-Smith by 49.3-48.6, a 0.8 point margin. In 2024, Donald Trump had defeated Kamala Harris in Mississippi by nearly 23 points. In Nate Silver’s final pre-election polls aggregate, Hyde-Smith had led by 6.5 points, so Colom greatly exceeded his polls.
This was the first Democratic win in a Mississippi Senate contest since 1982, when southern Democrats were still regarded as racist. It’s the first time a Black person has won the Mississippi Senate in 140 years, during the Reconstruction period that followed the Civil War.
Republican gerrymanders that backfired
Democrats lead in called seats in the House of Representatives by 256-169 with ten undecided. Of the undecided seats, Democrats lead in four, Republicans in four and two in Louisiana will go to runoffs on December 12. Republicans are likely to win both runoffs as they had a large majority of votes in both seats in November 3 “jungle primaries”. So Democrats are likely to win by a final 260-175. This would be Democrats’ largest House majority since the 1991-93 Congress.
Given Democrats’ national popular vote lead of 13.8 points in the Cook Political Report’s tracker, their 59.8% of seats is below expectations in a single-member system. At the Australian 2025 federal election, Labor won 62.7% of seats on a 10.5-point national two-party margin over the Coalition. At the UK 2024 general election, Labour won 63.2% of seats on a 10.0-point national popular vote margin over the Conservatives. There are relatively few competitive US House seats owing to gerrymanders, explaining Democrats’ underperformance relative to popular votes.
The Republican gerrymander that backfired most spectacularly was in North Carolina. In 2024, Republicans won the 14 NC House seats by 10-4. They tried to gain an extra seat by gerrymandering for an 11-3 Republican split. But the huge Democratic landslide wiped out Republican margins. Four NC seats haven’t been called yet, but Democrats are likely to win by 11-3.
In Texas, while Democrats gained a seat instead of Republicans gaining five (as per the gerrymander), Republicans had enough safe seats that they won Texas’ 38 House seats by 24-14 despite losing the popular vote in Texas by 5.7 points. In Florida, there was no net gain with Republicans holding the 28 Florida House seats by 20-8 (a four-seat Republican gain was expected from the gerrymander). Republicans won the Florida popular vote by 2.2 points.
In Tennessee, the Republican gerrymander had split Memphis into three House seats. While Republicans won all these seats, they appear to have lost another Tennessee seat by 0.14 points. In Alabama, Democrats held a seat they were expected to lose after gerrymandering. Republican gerrymanders will only work as expected in Louisiana, provided they win both runoffs on December 12.
Republican Lauren Boebert has been defeated in Colorado’s fourth House district. Democrats have gained the governorships of Texas, Georgia, Ohio, Iowa and Nevada, with Alaska to come.