The latest reading of the BludgerTrack poll aggregate finds at least some of the gloss coming off Malcolm Turnbull’s honeymoon poll ratings, with Labor gaining half a point on two-party preferred since last week and clawing back a point on the seat projection. This week’s Newspoll result means there are now two useable data points this year for personal ratings, the other being the monthly reading from Essential Research that was released a fortnight ago, and they collectively indicate a double-digit drop in Turnbull’s net approval rating since the end of last year, and a downturn in his standing on preferred prime minister. Nonetheless, Turnbull retains commanding leads, and the Coalition is credited with a bigger two-party vote and seat majority than was achieved at the 2013 election.
BludgerTrack: 53.7-46.3 to Coalition
Aggregated poll ratings find Malcolm Turnbull falling short of the heights he achieved towards the end of last year, without giving Labor any real cause for optimism about the election due later this year.
Reading that long analysis of the character of Malcolm Turnbull one thing jumped out at me and it may be indicative of his fatal flaw.
You saw it when he was ‘gently’ elbowed sideways from the Bar to Merchant Banking.
You saw it when he fell for the Godwin Grech email scam.
You saw it when he went to the Nationals party room and exclaimed that he owned more cattle than all of them combined.
You saw it when he selected Mal Brough and Arthur Sinodinos, both under clouds of suspicion for dodgy behaviour.
You’ve just seen it with the tax reform debate.
Malcolm Turnbull talks a big game, puffs himself up, is full of hot air, then crashes and burns like the Hindenburg.
[Amy Feldtmann @AmyFeldtmann 17m17 minutes ago
Five mths ago today, Aus govt announced it was taking 12,000 Syrian/Iraqi refugees. This takes time but to only have settled *26* = farcical]
From the Guardian blog. No comment necessary:
[The immigration minister Peter Dutton is on ABC radio in Melbourne now. He says the government is determined to ensure that new arrivals don’t fill detention centres.
Host Jon Faine is determined to emerge from this interview with a commitment for some kind of transparency. Faine points out that the asylum issue is now so divisive in Australia, it might be time to start some healing, some bringing of people together. PDuddy says the national healing will start when some journalists start looking at border protection in a “dispassionate” way. Faine blows a short gasket.
Hang on, he says, you want to talk about facts? How about opening our offshore detention facilities for scrutiny? Dutton notes the host is ignorant of the facts. Faine insists he’s not ignorant of any facts, he knows he can’t go to Nauru. He asks if the minister will facilitate a visit to the island, given there’s apparently no problem with scrutiny.
PDudd’s is somewhat in a corner here, but he’s a man inclined to press on, undaunted.
PDuddy: ‘I have no problem with that Jon, but visa issue is a matter for the Nauru government.’
Faine ends the interview by noting he looks forward to his Nauru visit. PDuddy ends the interview by saying he looks forward to another conversation soon.]
You can add to the sell off part the fact that patients data will be available to private companies. How much privacy for you medical records do you want?
TPOF
[ABC Radio Melbourne
ABC Radio Melbourne – Verified account @774melbourne
ICYMI: @PeterDutton_MP w/ #Faine on misrepresentation of facts, emotion in reporting and visiting #Nauru: https://soundcloud.com/774-abc-melbourne/peter-dutton-with-jon-faine-on-774-abc-melbourne …
2:45 PM – 8 Feb 2016]
guytaur @ 1903,
‘ You can add to the sell off part the fact that patients data will be available to private companies.’
Which begins the humiliating process of these companies selecting who they want to cover with their premium services, paid for by the people who want and can afford these services and consigning those who they don’t really want to have anything to do with, but they have to because a Universal Service Obligation will be built into their government contracts, to those doctors like Dr Jayant Patel who they know are shonks.
confessions
[
Amy Feldtmann @AmyFeldtmann 17m17 minutes ago
Five mths ago today, Aus govt announced it was taking 12,000 Syrian/Iraqi refugees. This takes time but to only have settled *26* = farcical]
Coalition trained at the US military school of farce in Syria.
[Senators appear incredulous and call for a new plan after hearing news that US military’s $500m effort has resulted in training of only a handful of fighters
US has trained only ‘four or five’ Syrian fighters against Isis, top general testifies…… expressing incredulity that the Defense Department would seek another $600m to fund fighters she said the US was counting “on our fingers and toes”.]
http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2015/sep/16/us-military-syrian-isis-fighters
poroti:
Given Barnett was expecting WA alone would settle up to 1200 Syrians, to only have settled 26 is very poor.
Arse Covering 101:
‘ During a Senate estimates hearing on Monday night, a Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet official revealed Mr Turnbull only requested the investigation at 1.58pm – just two minutes before a fiery question time where the saga featured prominently.’
Read more: http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-news/stuart-robert-scandal-deepens-as-labor-demands-answers-over-ministerial-meeting-20160208-gmoxps.html#ixzz3zcVWZj8G
confessions
[
poroti:
Given Barnett was expecting WA alone would settle up to 1200 Syrians…]
Actually expecting or making such noises knowing P Duddy and crew had SFA intention of making much effort to deliver?
C@tmomma
Turnbull is not the messiah. He is a very naughty boy (who lacks judgment). 🙂
vanOnselenP: Why on earth did Abbott’s office approve Stuart Robert’s trip to China? More evidence of dysfunction for the second edition of Battleground.
guytaur
No point PVO focussing on Abbott. He was long ago dumped as PM. Turnbull didnt have to give a portfolio to Stuart Robert
kemal_atlay: The LGBTI refugees Australia has locked up on Manus Island & Nauru #auspol https://t.co/rNkpLSk9uP via @jlfeder https://t.co/Wdh3cUcGkE
victoria
Exactly. Why its good PvO focussing on it. No doubt then only question is why when Turnbull found out however late he just did not sack the Minister?
My bet is factional numbers in the party.
Wow things are bad for the Human Rights Commission when its Brandis to the rescue
srpeatling: AG Brandis now defending existence of Human Rights Commission from questions by government senator Macdonald https://t.co/P7nM3cK2sU
Good line by Shorten that Turnbull is outsourcing his leadership.
From Stephanie Peatling’s blog at Fairfax:
[Never underestimate the pettiness of your elected representatives.
Labor senator Jacinta Collins has been asking Tim Wilson, who was appointed to the commission by the Abbott government, about his international travel.
In return Liberal Party senator Ian Macdonald wants Professor Triggs to advise the committee about her international travel.
Senator Macdonald is “reluctant” to make the request because “it just seems an unfortunate waste of your time”.
Then why are you doing it, Senator Collins asks.]
Do they have an IQ test for Coalition Senators? Over 90 and they are ineligible to be nominated?
latingle: Turnbull calls in auditors as Lodge renovation cost heads to $15 million https://t.co/6SJrbGEzob via @FinancialReview
shanebazzi: .@GillianTriggs:findings were disturbing, children deeply traumatised, mentally ill, confirms all findings made over last 2-3 yrs #estimates
Good points:
‘ They did such a wonderful job with privatisng colleges and allowing private enterprise to use taxpayer’s money to enrich themselves. Now they want to give the same opportunity to their business mates to rort Medicare. I cannot believe how blatantly this government implements its ideology of pro business to the detriment of everyone except the businesses running it.
Commenter
Coriander
Location
Sydney
Date and time
February 09, 2016, 9:40AM
Can’t you just see the outcome. Patients getting emails & calls from “health” providers in the Philippines or Thailand or India offering cut-price cures for what ails them.’
Commenter
mitch of ACT
Date and time
February 09, 2016, 9:48AM
Read more: http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/the-pulse-live/politics-live-february-9-2016-20160208-gmoz3h.html#ixzz3zcYr1AtZ
Now there’s more than a hint of truth to the conjecture of getting calls from overseas medical services providers.
Remember the story which rose and sank very quickly about how Andrew Robb was working on a scheme whereby Australians would be able to access medical services in other countries, paid for by the Australian government and because they were cheaper.
Is this sell-off of Medicare the prelude to that?
Victoria@1910,
“Turnbull is not the messiah. He is a very naughty boy (who lacks judgment)” Turnbull’s mother called him the ‘Messiah’, unlike Brian’s mother.
[‘ During a Senate estimates hearing on Monday night, a Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet official revealed Mr Turnbull only requested the investigation at 1.58pm – just two minutes before a fiery question time where the saga featured prominently.’]
To be fair to Malcolm, he was waiting for Robert to come up with a suggestion on how to handle this issue.
terrimbutler: .@AustralianLabor on the government’s latest #Medicare attacks #auspol https://t.co/GArxjbdwQN
joshgnosis: Triggs says conditions on Nauru are dangerous and unsafe, and children and families should not be returned to detention. #estimates
jamesmassola: Coalition’s David Gillespie has told the party room that doing nothing is not an option on tax reform.
jamesmassola: Christopher Pyne replies to David Gillespie: “we are here to get elected” in party room discussion
jamesmassola: Malcolm Turnbull tells the Coalition party Room the only way to cut taxes is to cut government spending.
So we have live time leaking now?
guytaur
[jamesmassola: Christopher Pyne replies to David Gillespie: “we are here to get elected” in party room discussion]
How Christopher Pyne is that comment all about me.
zoomster
Either that or the press is in the room
zoomster
Sorry forgot to add my money is on the former as no coverage on 24
zoomster
How did son go on his overseas trip?
[Peter Hannam
Peter Hannam – Verified account @p_hannam
Australia to be isolated from #climate research if #CSIRO cuts proceed, WMO says http://www.smh.com.au/environment/climate-change/australia-to-be-isolated-from-global-research-after-csiro-climate-cuts-wmo-20160208-gmoydi.html … #auspol ]
Senator X’s voting record.
Read it for yourself and decide if he’s more right-wing than the liberals or, perhaps, more left-wing than Labor.
https://theyvoteforyou.org.au/people/senate/sa/nick_xenophon
PVO is mightly annoyed that Turnbull is having to deal with Stuart Robert. As evidenced by his tweet, it appears Credlin was angry with Stuart Robert cos he was auctioning a blue tie for a fundraiser
[Peter van Onselen
Peter van Onselen – Verified account @vanOnselenP
This anger was over auctioning a blue tie…not attending a $2m donors event in China which was approved! Seriously. …
3:03 PM – 8 Feb 2016]
[Sky News Australia
Sky News Australia – Verified account @SkyNewsAust
Labor piles pressure on PM over minister http://bit.ly/1T9fQWb
Embedded image]
Peatling:
[10:11am: Senator Macdonald now wants to know why the Human Rights Commission exists given there are human rights divisions within both the Attorney-General’s Department and the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade.
Because one is an independent statutory body and the others are government departments answerable to the government, Senator Brandis says.
He stops short of adding “Duh”.
Your taxes at work people.]
[10:11am: Senator Macdonald now wants to know why the Human Rights Commission exists given there are human rights divisions within both the Attorney-General’s Department and the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade.
Because one is an independent statutory body and the others are government departments answerable to the government, Senator Brandis says.
He stops short of adding “Duh”.
Your taxes at work people.]
Labor is going to be having a good QT today.
Minister in trouble. Medicare sell off. More loss of AS narrative for the government.
victoria
Quite well, I think. He successfully navigated his way from Milan to a ski resort, and from there to Genoa and the soccer camp. He did hit a minor hiccup when he got to the station near the camp, as apparently they didn’t have a taxi service, so he hitched!
So he hasn’t done at all badly for a 19 year old in a strange country, on his own for the first time (I don’t think he even went on a school camp).
He’s currently on the plane from Milan to Dubai.
Got some really gorgeous photos on facebook, particularly from Genoa, but he hasn’t been particularly communicative, so I won’t get all the details until he comes home on the weekend.
B—dy gerbils hid my post through 3 refreshes until I repeated it.
peg
not the point I was trying to make, which was a minor one about the way stats can be interpreted, not a comment about X himself.
Chris Ullman talking of Bilson return to cabinet due to minster loss. Reshuffle is going to happen at some point.
annajhenderson: #BREAKING Prime Minister urges dumped Cabinet Minister Bruce Billson to stay https://t.co/qtNALbTtxz @abcnews via @CUhlmann
Zoomster
Good on him! He has done rather well indeed. My parents are native of Italy and whilst I would never live there, it is quite a stunning country
Mal won’t raise taxes, says they must spend less. Yet the new hospital on Nauru will cost millions. All to keep up the farce that is ‘border protection’.
billson dumped. Going to resign from parliament and now Truffles asks him to stay. You gotta laugh at the shambles
CPSUnion: Medicare sell off. Bad for jobs, bad for privacy, bad for services. https://t.co/Vqa592GbAC #stopmedicareselloff https://t.co/l9kysct6sj
lizzie
I may have mentioned this a while ago. Know someone who is connected to someone in nat security. Therefore I am getting it secondhand. Anyhoo. They have stated that the budget for national security is unlimited.
As i have stated several times, Turnbulll was drafted to be the front man so that they could proceed with the agenda unimpeded and guarantee re election. people had better start waking up to this fraud asap
Haha. I just spotted this
[Rowan
Rowan – @FightingTories
Pyne also said ” We had to bring Malcolm in to win the election ” – Kitchen cabinet with Albo https://twitter.com/jamesmassola/status/696835929646870528 …]
victoria
This from journalist Tim Lester
telester: For Legal & Constitutional #estimates, the next 15 mins will be its most productive this morning – it’s morning tea.
Nothing has changed its still the same party of chaos and dysfunction that backed Abbott as PM