My assertion in the previous post that we faced a dry spell on the polling front hadn’t reckoned on Newspoll’s quarterly breakdowns, published today in The Australian. These combine the four Newspoll surveys conducted this year into a super-poll featuring various breakdowns from credible sample sizes (though I’d note that nothing seems to have come of talk that new industry standards would require that such breakdowns be provided in each poll individually, in a new spirit of transparency following the great pollster failure of 2019).
The latest numbers offer some particularly interesting insights into where the Coalition has been losing support over recent months. Whereas things have been reasonably stable in New South Wales (now 50-50 after the Coalition led 51-49 in the last quarter of 2020) and Victoria (where Labor’s lead narrows from 55-45 to 53-47), there have been six-point shifts in Labor’s favour in Western Australia (where the Coalition’s 53-47 lead last time has been reversed) and South Australia (51-49 to the Coalition last time, 55-45 to Labor this time). Labor has also closed the gap in Queensland from 57-43 to 53-47.
It should be noted here that the small state sample sizes are relatively modest, at 628 for WA and 517 for SA, implying error margins of around 4%, compared with around 2.5% for the larger states. I also observed, back in the days when there was enough state-level data for such things to be observable, that state election blowouts had a way of feeding into federal polling over the short term, which may be a factor in the poll crediting Labor with a better result than it has managed at a federal election in WA since 1983.
The gender breakdowns notably fail to play to the script: Labor is credited with 51-49 leads among both men and women, which represents a four-point movement to Labor among men and no change among women. There is also nothing remarkable to note in Scott Morrison’s personal ratings, with deteriorations of 7% in his net rating among men and 8% among women.
Further results suggest the government has lost support more among the young (Labor’s lead is out from 61-39 to 64-36 among those aged 18 to 34, while the Coalition holds a steady 62-38 lead among those 65 and over), middle income earners (a three-point movement to Labor in the $50,000 to $100,000 cohort and four-point movement in $100,000 to $150,000, compared with no change for $50,000 and below and a two-point increase for the Coalition among those on $150,000 and over), non-English speakers (a four-point decline compared with one point for English speakers) and those with trade qualifications (a four-point movement compared with none among the university educated and one point among those without qualifications).
You can find the full results, at least on voting intention, in the poll data feature on BludgerTrack, where you can navigate your way through tabs for each of the breakdowns Newspoll provides for a full display of the results throughout the current term. Restoring a permanent link to all this through my sidebar is part of the ever-lengthening list of things I need to get around to.
ItzaDream
“Turnbull is loathed by the Conservatives as a traitor useless to their cause.”
He’s loathed by many Progressives for much the same reason. Fizzer.
Danama Papers @ #124 Tuesday, April 6th, 2021 – 11:26 am
Sure, but he’d want to give a bit of love to Victoria where he was virtually unseen during the lockdown and attacks from the Libs.
Apologies for yet more railing against Australia’s demonstrably ill-considered and patently inadequate vaccine selection, procurement and manufacturing strategies – and our current doubling down on these inexplicably unimaginative, unresilient (from the outset) approaches.
Least-efficacious for 80% of Australians isn’t good enough. We can still change course. We should.
Possibly reflective of our imprudent bet, yesterday The New York Times published a first-rate article on the continuing evolution of mRNA COVID vaccines. The article is highly recommended. The NVD-HXP-S vaccine is something to keep an eye on.
Researchers Are Hatching a Low-Cost Coronavirus Vaccine, The New York Times, 5 April 2021, https://www.nytimes.com/2021/04/05/health/hexapro-mclellan-vaccine.html
Ven @ #145 Tuesday, April 6th, 2021 – 11:53 am
Scott Morrison aped Menzies’, ‘The Forgotten People’ speech in the first speech he gave as PM, ‘The Quiet Australians’.
‘Barney in Tanjung Bunga says:
Tuesday, April 6, 2021 at 11:50 am
boerwar @ #138 Tuesday, April 6th, 2021 – 9:46 am
‘Barney in Tanjung Bunga says:
Tuesday, April 6, 2021 at 11:40 am
Ven @ #129 Tuesday, April 6th, 2021 – 9:34 am
Lizzie@10:40 am
When did we work together?
Well, the best example is working together in late 80s and early 90s to reduce CFCs gases, which were causing Ozone hole on southern pole. A big hole is now reduced significantly. I am not sure whether it is fully gone.
Or take the Pandemic example. World is working together to solve it. It became a huge issue, US government did not cooperate with the world for a whole year.
That was a relatively easy one that basically no impact on peoples daily lives.’
Well, as it turns out, no.
We were using a CFC (methyl bromide) to significantly boost production in our strawberry farm. The rules applied to Australia straight away but not to other countries.
The direct result is that for several years we had to compete against cheap strawberry imports from countries that were allowed to keep using CFCs to boost their strawberry production.
WOW!!!
You’re still looking for the magic switch I see.’
You raised CFC control. You claimed that no-one was personally affected by the CFCs ban. I gave you a personal example to show that that was not so. Your reference to a ‘magic switch’ is, in the circumstances, faintly ridiculous.
But while we are on the topic of ‘magic switches’, what is your take on the current Chinese invasion of the Philippines EEZ by a fleet of 200 vessels with orders to shoot? AOK? Not to be discussed in polite company? Flick the ‘magic switch’ and talk about something else? What?
North Korea’s sports ministry said on Tuesday that it will not participate in the Tokyo Olympics this year to protect its athletes amid the coronavirus pandemic.
The decision was made at a meeting of North Korea’s Olympic committee, including its sports minister Kim Il guk, on 25 March the ministry said on its website, called Joson Sports. “The committee decided not to join the 32nd Olympics Games to protect athletes from the global health crisis caused by the coronavirus,” it said.
lizzie @ #146 Tuesday, April 6th, 2021 – 11:55 am
Great question.
No vax no entry.
Ven:
Tuesday, April 6, 2021 at 11:43 am
[‘Mavis@10:48am
Have you seen Morrison favourability where it 65% amongst men and 49% amongst women?’]
No, I haven’t seen this. Do you have a link?
boerwar
Given how many are testing positive on arrival I wonder how many people are catching it from them on the plane ? They are on non direct flights so it would involve risk of spread to a number of other countries.
ItzaDream @ #150 Tuesday, April 6th, 2021 – 11:59 am
He was only ever used by them to win elections and for the junkyard dogs to hide behind.
DP@11:26 am
Albo was a competent and scandal free Minister .
Before one goes to any job interview people advice that person that he/she must sell themselves ( i.e. sell their skills and personality).
IMO, Albo doesn’t do that.
India surpasses 100,000 daily COVID-19 infections for the first time as politicians stage massive election rallies
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-04-05/india-surpasses-record-100-000-daily-covid-cases-new-variant/100049824
Donald Trump is available for ‘Weddings Parties Anything’ (no really!):
https://youtu.be/sgloP8wy-1s
Jaeger @ #161 Tuesday, April 6th, 2021 – 12:06 pm
Gotta win their votes while they are still alive! 🙄
DP
To answer your question, if and its a big if but if there was a global minimum wage i would set the amount in U.S dollars then convert it to the local currency. The odds of it happening are small and basing it on currencies would be very difficult to manage.
‘poroti says:
Tuesday, April 6, 2021 at 12:04 pm
boerwar
Given how many are testing positive on arrival I wonder how many people are catching it from them on the plane ? They are on non direct flights so it would involve risk of spread to a number of other countries.’
I don’t know. Things are harder to work out now than when there was little or no international travel and few, if any, community transmissions in Australia. I can’t help but feel our risk exposures are increasing at quite a rapid rate. We get our second AZ in 12 weeks. What are the recommended behaviours at that stage?
Simon Katich @ #135 Tuesday, April 6th, 2021 – 11:44 am
Yes yes we’re not spending enough billions on war toys for the warmongers who destroy the lives of their ADF personnel and their families.
Sheridan is a deranged pathetic shill.
Dumping turnbull Gladys showed again she is controlled by Newsltd , Morrison and his cronies, may have help Labor more than they could ask for
It is easy and cheap to get the mandatory PCR negative or Vaccine certificate on the internet (Google this..)
So do all the sub-continent people coming to Aus/NZ have to present a negative certificate before they board the plane? Yes they do.
Is every certificate legit? Probably not.
If I was a permanent residency or citizenship holder in India and had got C19, then convalescing Down Under would be worth a few Crore…
Also in Labor’s favour is the hate of each other in the Turnbull and Abbott camps
[‘The Berejiklian government has dumped former prime minister Malcolm Turnbull from his role as head of an advisory body on climate change, saying the focus of the position should not be based on personality.
The move, announced on Tuesday morning, follows days of attacks on his appointment from what Mr Turnbull called “the right-wing media ecosystem”. “It’s just thuggery,” he told the Herald.’]
It goes without saying that Morrison’s mitts are all over this. But given Turnbull’s gutless dealings with the trogs in his party re. climate change, he can’t really complain.
https://www.smh.com.au/environment/climate-change/thuggery-turnbull-blames-media-beat-up-for-dumping-from-climate-role-20210406-p57gs9.html
Even the Ruperts are not impressed with the roll out. Look out Scomo and Ghunt.
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/speed-of-australias-vaccine-rollout-ranked-90th-in-the-world-expert-says/news-story/c83334da4890ad786b21e4d8bc6a386d
I am no fan of Monarchy or Prince Charles. However on this issue a man with historic credibility speaks up for science and expertise
@GerardZkutney tweets
Prince Charles: “It is baffling, I must say, that in our modern world we have such blind trust in science and technology that we all accept what science tells us about everything—until, that is, it comes to climate science.”
#ClimateCrisis #climatechange
Boerwar has not been the same since bluey his imaginary octopus was eaten at a Manuka Chinese restaraunt.
V. Sad
Hopefully the one bright light out the India Covid S#itshow is that it could bring down Narendra Modi.
Boer claimed ignorance of my position re ‘what to do’ about the ‘Chinese fishing fleet’ in the South China Sea.
Which seems odd, since my post at 6.18pm last night on the previous thread – which I set out below – was responded to by the Boer at 8.20pm …
______
“ As I commented the other day boorish Boer, if the US’s China containment policy is ever going to be anything more than piss and wind, NOW is the time for the 7th Fleet to confiscate or sink that Chinese ‘fishing fleet’ menacing the Philippines.
I’ll not hold my breath though. Piss and wind, signifying … nothing … Xi will just ratchet up the Taiwan-HK-etc prods until he does get a serious response. Again, I’ll not hold my breath.
Now that Morrison has volunteered us for front line service, completely out of the blue and against our national interest and 50 years hard diplomatic work, AND America has drawn a metaphorical line in the sand over the Chi-coms treatment of us, I expect a good almighty Xi prod in our general direction … and I’ll not hold my breath for America to actually DO anything other than vent even more piss and wind. …
All this Sabre rattling is just fucking hopeless. As Tuco said in The Good, the Bad, the Ugly ‘if you are going to shoot, shoot …’ I’ll not hold my breath.”
So, there you go.
My position: let Biden unleash the 7th fleet if he’s serious about ‘China Containment’.
If he’s not, then that’s a pretty strong signal that Australia has royally fucked itself by signing up for front line service on a policy that even the Americans aren’t serious about. It’s a pretty good indication that some future American Administration will cut and run from its alliance obligations to Australia if they become inconvenient to Uncle Sam.
dave@11:47am
Increase corporate tax (OMG, OMG OMG)
It is so socialist in terms of current economic thinking i.e. to increase corporate tax in US .
There must be so much wringing of hands in LNP circles because Tellen, who was ex-Chair of Federal reserve is going to ask the world especially US allies to do the same
The failed CovidSafe app could be re-purposed based on the Israeli model….
‘Membership in the class is certified by the Green Pass, a document you can download and carry in your phone. It includes a sort of GIF, a little moving animation of green people walking along, looking like a happy, fully vaccinated family.’
https://www.nytimes.com/2021/04/05/world/middleeast/israel-vaccinations.html
Baffled is a good word for Charles; he looks perpetually so. Anyway, baffle not Charles. The denial of the science of climate change is driven on one hand by the self serving hip pocket brigade, something Charles might know something about, and on the other, by the lunatic pre-Copernicans like that fruit cake who was saying the missing plane flew too high above the clouds and got too close to god, or something.
Barney@11:40 am
Two things
1. It shows world governments can cooperate
2. Do you know the significance of Ozone hole at that time?
Crikey’s take on the government’s submission to current wage case
https://twitter.com/crikey_news/status/1379242534648520707?s=20
or
https://www.crikey.com.au/2021/04/06/wages-growth-australia-2021/
The ‘boning’ is official, with ‘Liberal Moderate” Matt Kean sent out to do the public knifing…
A-E
Thanks for that.
I rather like the general drift of your post.
The tricky question that arises is this.
Is there some point at which the US feels that it has no option but to start the shooting?
Will China keep pressing until we get there?
Not Czechoslovakia but Poland, yes?
Not inside the 9 Dash Line but Taiwan, yes?
spr
Another win for Rupert.
Yes, the meeting has happened, but the collection of photos don’t show a happy little group of vegemites.
Mavis@22:04 pm
Link is WBs article
https://www.pollbludger.net/2021/03/31/essential-research-morrison-approval-and-gender-issues/
OC,
thanks for your comments on the independent health service purchaser-provider architecture.
I’m not sold. Competition in these types of markets is highly over-rated.
My wife was working at Southampton University Hospital as the first wave of this type of reform was being rolled out, managing an allied health department. So I’ve seen some of how this plays out up close.
In addition to their regular work, they had to effectively reapply for their own positions, vs two private providers of the same services (with no track record). The private providers had super-glossy proposals and undercut the hospital (they knew the hospital trust’s cost profile). They won out, and then hired many of the existing hospital staff at lower rates of pay with worse conditions, and worse levels of service to patients.
Two big issues stand out for me (among the many):
– How is an interdisciplinary case management team supposed to work when the different services are provided by different organisations, within the one hospital?
– Standards of care come down to what’s written in a contract, not what best for the patient – how is this managed? What oversight is there?
It is very, very expensive to write encompassing contracts, and impossible to write a complete contract for all contingencies. Some economist won a prize for that recently. Their conclusion was to keep it all in one firm.
So yes, I’m not sold at all.
China Tests Biden With South China Sea Tactic That Misled Obama
Based on the official view from Beijing, the Philippines has no reason to worry about Chinese fishing boats sitting along a disputed reef in the South China Sea.
The vessels — initially numbering in the hundreds — were simply “taking shelter from the wind” and the Philippines should view the situation in a “rational light,” Chinese Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Hua Chunying said on March 22 when the news first broke.
Two weeks later, more than 40 boats are still at Whitsun Reef and the statements are getting more and more terse.
“If your goal is to take over a sea space and atoll without fighting for it, this is a brilliant if dishonest tactic,” said Carl Schuster, a former operations director at U.S. Pacific Command’s Joint Intelligence Center. “Only professional seamen know it’s a lie — no one ‘shelters’ their ships in a storm area weeks ahead of a storm.
All in all, it’s beginning to look more and more like Beijing is probing whether President Joe Biden will take any action after pledging to work with allies in the region to deter Chinese assertiveness.
“It is a test to see what the administration is willing to do,” said Schuster, who is now an adjunct faculty member of Hawaii Pacific University’s diplomacy and military science program. “How the U.S. reacts will determine the next test.
One big problem is how to calibrate the response. China’s use of commercial fishing boats amounts to a “gray zone” tactic that allows Beijing to deny anything is amiss. Sending an aircraft carrier or other warships near the reef risks appearing like an overreaction that would make the U.S. look like the aggressor.
On the other hand, doing nothing could look weak.
The Biden administration also reaffirmed that the U.S.-Philippine defense treaty covers any attacks in the South China Sea, a clarification made under President Donald Trump that came after decades of official ambiguity.
Philippine leader Rodrigo Duterte, who has undermined the alliance while hailing closer ties with Beijing.
“The Americans are wary of wading into this and not knowing if they’ll end up being blamed for escalating the situation, which is a real possibility with the capricious leadership in Manila,” he said.
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-04-05/china-tests-biden-with-south-china-sea-tactic-that-misled-obama?srnd=premium-asia
https://youtu.be/1r3S5UKP7ME
I think China is angling for a future American administration to admit that its ‘China containment’ policy and associated ‘America first’ trade wars are failures and to simply give up and return to an isolationist stance reminiscent of the Republican Party of the 1930s before it actually makes a move directly against Taiwan.
Until then, it’s a case of prod prod prod on a range of issues – which now includes Australia, thanks to our dickhead-in-chief – until America gives up.
In the meantime, for every ‘freedom of navigation’ exercise, China will reclaim some reef and turn it into another militarised island. Every time Australia sticks it’s head up, or is mentioned in dispatches, we will get a trade whack (to the fulmination but nothing else from ‘the Quad’). Every time someone bleats about democracy Hong Kong will get another whack. When someone talks human rights, the Quigars or Tibetians will get the special sauce.
No one seems to consider that having policies that have better than a snowflake’s chance in hell of being actually effective is as important, in fact more important, as ‘having positions’. Boer: – this is exactly the sort of self indulgent behaviour that you (and moi for that matter) rail against The Greens about.
CFC stands for ChloroFluoroHydrocarbon(s), commonly used as refrigerant gases, in refrigerators and air conditioners. Monsanto used to make them in a plant in Rozelle, next to the Iron Cove bridge. Methyl bromide is not a CFC.
I am sure they will do it, but I am not sure how good the look of having a bunch of women sitting behind the PM in Question Time is going to be. Might look a little subservient.
Researchers reworking UQ COVID vaccine to fight viruses in the future
https://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/national/queensland/researchers-reworking-uq-covid-vaccine-to-fight-viruses-in-the-future-20210405-p57go2.html
Ven:
Tuesday, April 6, 2021 at 12:30 pm
[‘Mavis@22:04 pm
Link is WBs article.’]
[‘This 16% gender gap on prime ministerial approval is twice as big as the Newspoll record from 1996 to the present…’]
Thanks. I guess that Morrison thinks this is only a temporary setback as women, in his ’50s mindset, will ultimately come to their senses, using Jen as his yardstick.
Lol. ‘Until America gives up’.
Yep, that’s totally going to happen. 🙄
The Liberals would be a bit nervous about their support among women because they only usually win elections if they carry the women vote.
Lloyd Austin III, is no Robert Gates.
China was previously given the benefit of the doubt. That’s not going to happen again.
And for anyone who brings up the , now, tired old canard of, ‘but China makes our stuff!’, then let me say that there are plenty of other countries who are just itching to take over the contracts for ‘making our stuff’, just as efficiently and for as low a cost as China. India and Vietnam are 2 who come quickly to mind. Not to mention the garment industry of Bangladesh. And that’s not even considering plenty of countries in Africa.
China will be spanked. They’ll have earned it. And Australia’s Trade Balance will remain relatively unaffected. Eg Barley and Wine.
This advert keeps following me around on websites I visit, including PB. I can’t think what I have done to deserve it!
Mavis
It might be time to retire the “50s mindset” because was Morrison even alive in the 50s.
Many in today’s Liberal party are still fighting the early 1990s.
Mexicanbeemer @ #194 Tuesday, April 6th, 2021 – 1:15 pm
And it was tertiary-educated women that were the bedrock of the Republican Party vote as well but who deserted them during Trump, to the point that the Republicans are now circulating emails about how they must appeal to ‘Working Class Males’. 🙂
But what really swung it for Biden was the working class women who also deserted Trump from 2016.