The Australian brings us a second Newspoll in consecutive weeks, perhaps portending weekly results from now to the election. It shows no change from last week on two-party preferred, with Labor maintaining its 52-48 lead, but both major parties are up on the primary vote – Labor by two and the Coalition by one, leaving them tied on 39%. The Greens are steady on 9% and One Nation are, interestingly, down two to 4%. All we are told of the leaders’ ratings at this stage is that they are “virtually unchanged”. Scott Morrison is unchanged on 45% approval and up one to 44% disapproval; Bill Shorten is unchanged on both measures, at 37% and 51%; and preferred prime minister is likewise unchanged, at 46-35 in favour of Morrison. The poll was conducted Thursday to Sunday from a sample of 1697.
Newspoll: 52-48 to Labor
The first published opinion poll of the campaign records no change in Labor’s modest yet decisive lead.
Matt
ABC did not have polling. They did however ask voters in Liberal seats in Victoria who they were going to vote for in Vox pop fashion. All said not Liberal. Reporters comment was these voters in “safe” Liberal seats were not hard to find.
BH wrote…
I’ll pass on the well wishes of everyone here to Louise, the owner.
Lou has had a few dogs over the years. She likes the company, and she’s a sucker for a sad story, or a dog down on its luck. She gave 110% to get Ruby over the line, but Ruby became too mental to handle and, in the vet’s assessment (the vet knew Ruby quite well) had changed comprehensively, just in the past few months, and would have started chewing on people, soon, not just brush turkeys. Ruby was not having fun under the house chasing her demons. She was in great distress: a distress that nothing – not food, sleep, nor love – could deal with. It was awful to witness.
Lou has a cat as well. We had a laugh between the tears this morning, joking that it was the cat that had told Ruby about a large nest of rats under the house, tough rats, rats that needed lots of barking to root out. Go get ’em Ruby!
The cat’s life has changed for the better since Ruby took up living under the house. As far as the cat’s concerned Ruby could have stayed there permanently. They never got on at all. The cat will be pleased Ruby’s gone.
For myself, I always had a feeling that Ruby was destined for a bad end. She had too big a personality, far too little restraint and very large teeth. That can be a bad combination.
The power of grassroots activism – GetUp
https://www.theage.com.au/federal-election-2019/our-approach-is-to-remove-the-hard-right-getup-raises-12m-in-effort-to-oust-conservatives-20190414-p51e3c.html
Clem Attlee says:
Monday, April 15, 2019 at 4:57 pm
Aren’t we all animals?
Or do they only like the cute furry ones? 🙂
https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2019/apr/15/pressure-for-integrity-commission-builds-as-poll-reveals-loss-of-trust-in-politics
Sohar @ #780 Monday, April 15th, 2019 – 6:02 pm
New from 3rd April!
https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2019/apr/15/aec-warns-unions-over-fake-eviction-notices-posted-at-liberal-mps-offices
Andrew Probyn
@andrewprobyn
Verified account
Hearing Brian Fisher, a well-known skeptic of climate action, has been asked by the coalition to “cost” Labor’s energy policy … We should see some of his work tomorrow. Dr Fisher warns of 10,000 jobs being lost under ALP policy … There’s a pattern emerging methinks…
Just got polled by Ucost/Ucomm? normal questions plus a lot of questions on indigenous rights.
As an atheist, Easter doesn’t have any special meaning for me.
______
Firefox
As a fisherman Easter has special meaning for me.
High tides!
Pegasus @ #805 Monday, April 15th, 2019 – 6:27 pm
Did you notice one of your regular assertions was skewered with this latest Newspoll? A big swing to major Parties as the second tier boutique parties lose ground. Looks like voters will be going the full lmonty in this Election.
Rob Gibbs, leukemia sufferer, has a go at Shorten because he doesn’t like politicians.
And this is front page material? An “unscripted moment”, in a campaign that (the journalists claims) had so far gone off like clockwork?
Did Bill Shorten promise a cure for cancer? Did he put out a policy that ensures cancer sufferers receive miracle cures? That they don’t suffer?
I don’t think so.
I can understand Mr Gibbs being cheesed off at having to pay a $1500 imaging bill this morning, but really, what could Shorten have done about that? What could Dan Andrews have done about it?
You cannot run the country from Opposition. That’s why we have elections.
That a journalist – more accurately: a subbie writing headlines – thinks this is a disaster for Labor, is pathetic and a shame on the newly tabloid SMH, more concerned with Reality TV as reality, than the real issues in this election.
https://www.smh.com.au/federal-election-2019/who-do-the-battlers-back-leukaemia-sufferer-rob-challenges-bill-shorten-on-cancer-promise-20190415-p51ec6.html
Citizen,
Thanks for cheering me up. Listening to ABC radio during the day while driving is really depressing.
Perhaps FDOTM is also listening to ABC radio. His cartoon explains how I feel. Hope we are both wrong:
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/apr/15/scott-morrison-is-going-to-win-the-2019-federal-election-are-you-ready?utm_term=RWRpdG9yaWFsX0ZpcnN0RG9nT25UaGVNb29uLTE5MDQxNQ%3D%3D&utm_source=esp&utm_medium=Email&utm_campaign=FirstDogOnTheMoon&CMP=firstdog_email
If you are not a subscriber don’t use outline for this. Subscribe. They have a weekly rate. So you can subscribe for the election period and unsubscribe later if you like.
This is a good read IMO.
https://www.crikey.com.au/2019/04/15/warringah-fight-tony-abbott/
($)
GG
It’s the long-term trend that matters, not one poll.
Zali Steggall speaks about that creepy Capt GetUp video. Haven’t seen any comment from Abbott distancing himself from, or calling out the video for its sick imputations.
#FakeCostings
https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/ng-interactive/2019/apr/15/who-should-i-vote-for-policy-guide-to-the-2019-australian-election
Those expecting only the Coalition and Labor to be included will be as surprised as I was to see the Greens included as a major party.
Bernard Keane nails Morrison for a whopping carbon emissions lie.
Morrison boasts how the Coalition fixed our ‘climate deficit’
Of course, the government is using a special exemption for Australia to claim it met its first and will meet its second Kyoto target. But we’re fascinated by Morrison’s claims that he inherited a “climate deficit”.
Let’s examine the most recent data on carbon emissions from Morrison’s own bureaucrats, snuck out last year. And indeed, it shows Australia’s emissions falling alarmingly under Labor, to below 130 Mt of CO2-equivalent every quarter under Labor’s carbon pricing scheme. But the Coalition has indeed turned that around and, having abolished Labor’s carbon pricing scheme and removed its dead hand from our emissions, it has lifted Australia’s emissions back up to nearly 135 Mt every quarter.
Of course, that’s not necessarily what Tony Abbott signed us up for as part of the Paris Agreement — we’re supposed to be on track to reducing emissions to below 112 Mt a quarter within 11 years. But since, as we’re told, fixing deficits is in the Liberal Party’s DNA, our kids and grandkids will just have to look after themselves.
https://www.crikey.com.au/2019/04/15/morrison-boasts-how-the-coalition-fixed-our-climate-deficit/
Pegasus @ #815 Monday, April 15th, 2019 – 6:34 pm
The long term trend is the Greens are dying. Eaten from the inside out with their poor choice of candidates, internecine fighting and not being able to articulate what they stand for.
Did anyone else get the email from GetUp encouraging people to enrol to vote?
I had this discussion with William a little while ago as to whether the marriage equality vote will put more younger people on the electoral roll this time around, or whether it just brought forward some enrolments. William seemed to be saying the latter (forgive me if I misread that William).
However, I’d still like to see the actual numbers. Especially after enrolments close.
Bernard Keane also points out how bad it’s going for the LNP.
Thanks to prepolling a lot of voters will have voted by the time of the last week of the campaign. Time is as much the enemy as Labor for the LNP.
So going on that brilliant tactics Labor. Getting the LNP not to campaign over Easter is not going to win them seats.
Having caught up on today’s thread, I see the supporters of a two-party state have been in full flight.
Your anti-democratic tendencies are showing.
Hewson lost because he couldn’t explain his own policies, Howard didn’t win 2001 during the campaign.
What is with this pant-wetting?
Morrison is not Howard …
I’m not delusional, elections can go wrong. But for Christ’s sake … if you don’t believe you’re going to win, I can guarantee you the outcome.
shiftaling @ #817 Monday, April 15th, 2019 – 6:35 pm
we should all share and keep saying this, outrageous…..
I enjoyed reading Frances Flanagan’s August 2018 piece entitled The Policy and Politics of Basic Income.
https://www.futurework.org.au/four_views_on_basic_income_job_guarantees_and_the_future_of_work
I share her conclusion that a UBI does not challenge the commodification of vast swathes of our social and cultural lives. In that sense, it is a policy that lacks ambition and imagination.
I would go further by observing that a UBI would be macroeconomically unstable. It has no inflation control built into it. This is the main practical reason to favour a targeted Basic Income over a Universal Basic Income.
A generous Basic Income that reflects the society’s productivity level should be provided to people of retirement age, people who are sick or injured, and people with disabilities.
A guarantee of good quality employment for all who want it would serve multiple purposes:
It would be an automatic stabilizer that targets just the right amounts of federal spending in just the right places to provide genuine full employment with price stability at all times.
It would be a public option for jobs that would widen the cultural imagination of what paid work can be and increase the quality of workplaces and job design for everyone (because people would have a good public option to turn to if the private sector failed to create interesting and fulfilling jobs and respectful workplaces).
It would empower cooperatives, not-for-profit social enterprises, NGOs, and local governments to design jobs that care for people and care for the planet.
It would make jobs a lot more flexible for people who experience disability, mental illness, personality disorders, substance addiction and other struggles that currently exclude them from fulfilling paid work.
Universal guarantees of good quality affordable housing, public services, and public infrastructure are also needed.
There is not much point in guaranteeing everyone a certain income if people are not getting the goods and services that they need for a decent life.
I think that government is designed to solve problems that are public, collective, and shared. The systemic and structural responses to the problems must also be public, collective, and shared. A UBI perpetuates the myth that our problems are primarily private and individualistic in character.
Increasing the social wage by providing public services and infrastructure with zero out of pocket fees is a much better way of lifting everybody’s living standards than a universal payment that significantly increases total demand but does not directly increase the supply of goods and services.
Legislating that a fixed portion of average productivity growth be allocated to a shorter working day, a shorter working week, and more weeks of annual leave is a much better way of increasing people’s leisure time than a UBI.
Using a Job Guarantee to drive the unemployment rate down to 1 or 2 percent, eradicate time-related under-employment, and eradicate hidden unemployment will do much more to increase workers’ bargaining power and working conditions than a UBI that would probably become a wage subsidy for employers rather than a net benefit for workers.
Changing employment law to favour workers would directly reduce exploitation in employment relationships. The Commonwealth Parliament could legislate to allow industry-wide bargaining, to allow unions to collect fees from non-members who benefited from agreements negotiated by the union, to make it easier for unions to access workplaces, to strengthen the rights of casual workers to upgrade to permanent employee status, to make labour hire firms and the ultimate employer jointly liable for meeting workplace health and safety and employment standards, to compel labour hire firms to get a license, and to widen the definition of employee to include any worker whose pay and conditions are determined mostly by one major firm.
The evidence doesn’t support the view that an employment relationship is inherently oppressive.
The exploitation stems from a macroeconomy that is far short of true full employment, and from employment law that heavily favours employers.
Address those two problems and the quality of employment improves dramatically.
Guaranteeing people good quality employment provides many psycho-social benefits that income alone cannot match.
By every relevant measure, employment guarantees and service guarantees thrash the UBI concept hands down.
Bluey had a mate who was into sabres and it hurt.
Was he a Swordfish? 🙂
D&M:
FYI we’ve had success in reaching out to a national science academy to secure its eminent scientist for National Science Week keynote presentation and school incursions here. And not only is she a woman (always great to profile women in the sciences, esp for younger generations), but she’s based in WA, and her research interests have relevance to our region.
I just wanted to say thanks to you for making enquiries with your networks, even if it didn’t amount to anything concrete in the end.
Pegasus @ #823 Monday, April 15th, 2019 – 6:41 pm
*yawn*
Pegasus @ #815 Monday, April 15th, 2019 – 6:34 pm
Yeah it’s a flatline with a slow downward trend. 🙂
Cud:
I have absolutely no doubt that the ME vote mobilised first time voters to get themselves onto the electoral roll. At the time there were a few PBers who had kids/grandkids/nieces/nephews who were chomping at the bit to enroll so they could vote in the plebiscite.
Confessions,
Thanks for letting me know. I hope it all goes really well for you!
C@tmomma @ #829 Monday, April 15th, 2019 – 6:44 pm
The Greens are welcome to displace the LNP.
C@tmomma @ #830 Monday, April 15th, 2019 – 6:45 pm
The Doctors call it Greenies Droop!
Nicholas. Once again you descend into hand waving generalisations loaded with value judgements about human behaviour. It’s unbecoming because sometimes you talk sense. But on the subject of a UBI you’re ideologically driven.
Thanks D&M. I’m actually looking forward to helping pull it all together and attending some of the local activities.
Pegasus @ #807 Monday, April 15th, 2019 – 6:29 pm
Anti Union and doing the Liberals dirty work for them now, Pegasus, by putting that here?
Shame on you.
EGW @ #833 Monday, April 15th, 2019 – 6:47 pm
The trend of interest that I bring up and referred to by GG is the increasing vote share of the non-major parties, not the vote share of the Greens party.
Confessions
There is no doubt that once those young people were on the roll they were on it. I think it got a few on that would otherwise not have enrolled to vote.
Its easy to overstate the significance but it is significant given young people usually avoiding enrolling until later.
With regards enrollment of younger cohort following ME , I recall that either William or Kevin Bonham said that historically increases in enrollments in these types of situations just result in higher rates of not voting in following elections.
I could have imagined all this too…
EGW
Kudos for your clever riposte.
Pegasus @ #839 Monday, April 15th, 2019 – 6:50 pm
Pardon?
The latest Newspoll shows the exact opposite.
Major parties increasing their share of the vote.
Douglas and Milko,
You must have been over the moon, lol, last week to see those fine Australian astrophysicists and Mathematicians who made such outstanding contributions to locating and getting the world’s first photo of a black hole!
Congratulations to the Australian Women of Astrophysics! Bravo!
One poll does not make a trend.
EGW @ #838 Monday, April 15th, 2019 – 6:50 pm
‘Tis true, they are becoming bluer as time goes on.
Pegasus @ #845 Monday, April 15th, 2019 – 6:53 pm
It can certainly break one – if it ever existed.
Anyway, off to my branch meeting.
Have fun folks. :D:
Pegasus @ #839 Monday, April 15th, 2019 – 6:50 pm
Give me the beat boy and smooth my polls,
I want to get lost in those poor Greens polls
That vote just drifts away…….
The real significance of the ME survey was that it showed how far the LNP right had moved away from their electorates.
Its a political shockwave that saw the right panic and replace Turnbull.
Its part of the reason I think those “safe” seats are in danger. It woke the “moderate” Liberals up as well.