Weekend miscellany: Senate preselections, electoral reform latest and more (open thread)

Liberal Senator Hollie Hughes dumped to an unwinnable position on the Coalition’s New South Wales ticket, and a return of talk about extra territory Senators.

The big electoral news for the week was the publication on Friday of proposed new federal boundaries for Victoria and Western Australia, which you can read all about on the dedicated post. Other than that:

• New South Wales Liberal Senator Hollie Hughes was dumped to fourth position on the Coalition ticket after running third in a Liberal preselection vote last weekend, the third position on the ticket being reserved to the Nationals. The top places will go to moderate incumbent Andrew Bragg and conservative challenger Jess Collins, who earlier ran unsuccessfully for preselection in North Sydney and for Marise Payne’s Senate vacancy. Hughes is part of the struggling centre right faction, but had endorsement from Peter Dutton, Jacinta Price and Michaelia Cash, while Collins was endorsed by Angus Taylor and Joe Hockey. Linda Silmalis of the Daily Telegraph reports that “while the right were claiming a major win, the left claimed it was the result of a larger and less factional state council”. A distribution sheet showed Bragg scored 196 votes in the first round of voting to 146 for Collins, 145 for Hughes and 51 for also-ran Lincoln Parker, which became a 191 to 167 vote win for Collins over Hughes after distribution of Parker’s votes and Bragg’s 16-vote surplus.

• The second position on Labor’s Queensland Senate ticket appears set to go to Corrine Mulholland, in-house lobbyist at Star casinos and the party’s candidate for Petrie in 2022. This follows the withdrawal of her two mooted rivals, former state minister Kate Jones and former Townsville mayor Jenny Hill. Jones had been backed by Left faction heavyweight Gary Bullock in a scheme that would have overturned a convention that the top two positions be shared between the Left, whose incumbent Nita Green will lead the ticket, and the Right, which is backing Mulholland.

• The West Australian reports preselection runner-up Howard Ong, IT consultant and former Australian Christian Lobby activist, has been confirmed as the new Liberal candidate for Tangney following the withdrawal of the initial winner, Mark Wales.

• Special Minister of State Don Farrell told Senate estimates on Thursday that the government had been seeking a cross-party deal on electoral reform that included doubling the number of Senators for the two territories, and that legislation could be expected “soon”. The government also hopes to introduce truth-in-advertising laws and real-time disclosure of campaign donations of greater than $10,000.

• I belatedly observe that Nine Newspapers’ report on Resolve Strategic’s quarterly state breakdowns includes data for Western Australia and South Australia for four sets of quarterly aggregations over the last year, where normally the pollster’s breakdowns are only for the three larger states.

Author: William Bowe

William Bowe is a Perth-based election analyst and occasional teacher of political science. His blog, The Poll Bludger, has existed in one form or another since 2004, and is one of the most heavily trafficked websites on Australian politics.

829 thoughts on “Weekend miscellany: Senate preselections, electoral reform latest and more (open thread)”

Comments Page 16 of 17
1 … 15 16 17
  1. FUBAR….
    Interested in your final option for say Round-World-BC air fare…Before CV, picked this option up for about x3 and x4 of steerage…..with Malaysian in the day….So – back then – round $5 to $6k. Son just paid $24,000HK for one way BC flight HK-Perth so don’t think “cheap” fares for are on the table yet. Take you point about leg room………………

  2. ‘FUBAR says:
    Tuesday, June 4, 2024 at 5:53 pm

    Boerwar says:
    Tuesday, June 4, 2024 at 4:34 pm

    Currently planning our next Hong Kong – Europe jaunt. Can’t decide on a round-the-world ticket or just straight back from Europe. I like to book through our extremely helpful Flight Centre – because when it all goes to poo, they sort it out – unlike when you book it all yourself online. The Business Class prices are still a bit too pricey – I like the extra legroom and flat bed sleeping but not that much.’
    ———————–
    Make sure you not in Honkers at the wrong time.

  3. Hastie caught between supporting his own idea or his always naysaying leader.
    His idea is crap, that’s why Labor adopted it.

  4. Liberal Howard owns Australia’s entry into the Afghanistan War. Yet another massive Liberal Howard idiot idea.
    Every prime minister up to and including Morrison thereafter bears some accountability for Australia’s most pointless war effort since the Boer War.

  5. Socrates says:
    Tuesday, June 4, 2024 at 6:02 pm

    “When were you there?”

    Never.

    I know plenty of people who did go and did multiple deployments. Outside of the SF group – which was over worked – everyone else I know was pretty happy to do their rotations – it’s their job. it’s what they train for and the money was bloody good.

  6. Badthinkersays:
    Tuesday, June 4, 2024 at 6:09 pm
    Hastie caught between supporting his own idea or his always naysaying leader.
    —————————————
    His idea is crap, that’s why Labor adopted it.
    =================================================

    Is that also the reason he is the LNP’s defence spokesperson too. All his idea’s are crap?.

  7. Badthinker @ #744 Tuesday, June 4th, 2024 – 5:50 pm

    Labor pinched a poor L-NP ADF recruitment idea because they’ve got none of their own?

    Labor has never seen a COALition policy they didn’t like. Possibly excepting nuclear, although the jury is still out on that one – I for one am expecting them to quietly adopt that one as well, as soon as they think they can get away with it.

  8. Player One
    …

    By not criticing Nuclear Power on health and safety grounds, Labor has signaled it’s open to a backflip in opposition if Dutton backflips on the Build in Government.

  9. Not hearing much about Rishi Sunak’s compulsory military service for 18 year olds.

    We’ll know Dutton is desperate if he picks this up as an election commitment. He obviously thinks it would be character building…

    And to lower the standards of entry, to lower the entry requirements in the way that the government is proposing, regardless of which version you look at, that is cheapening what should be a vocation that every Australian looks up to and respects.”

  10. @Sprocket at 6:34pm

    From what I’ve read in the UK media, it was an idea so ridiculed from left, right and centre that the Tories don’t seem to want to talk about it anymore.

    An absolute stink-bomb of a policy.

  11. Labor has never seen a COALition policy they didn’t like.

    Every once in a while I think you’re a good faith commenter and then you disabuse me of such folly with unabashed nonsense like this.

  12. From the Community Disability Alliance-Hunter (CDAH):

    Tuesday, June 4. CDAH funding cut. This funding was started by the Morrison government 4 years ago. But the Albanese government has cancelled it, not funded after June 30.

    Was the Morrison government more responsive to disability needs than the current Albanese government?

    Plenty of funding for a $300,000 plus/year speechwriter for NDIS Minister Bill Shorten. Plenty of $billions for Defence.

    But small needy groups like this are not his interest. I guess this cut is to save the Albanese government money. They will not donate to Labor after all.

    ‘No federal funding for DeafBlind community in the Hunter or NSW

    Last week CDAH were advised that the DeafBlind Hub and Community Connections Information Linkages and Capacity Building (ILC) projects would not be funded after June 30.

    This loss is a huge blow to the Deafblind community and people with a disability who live in closed systems throughout NSW.

    This is simply not good enough. Please join Community Disability Alliance – CDAH in the fight for real grassroots voice choice and control for those who’s voices are least heard’.

  13. Did you ever stop to think that maybe it was the ADF’s idea, which is why Hastie and now Marles have tested it out?

  14. The Australian 04/06
    The agency tasked with delivering Anthony Albanese’s $10bn affordable housing fund paid $24m to consultants and $6m in executive salaries last year, despite not yet completing a single house.
    _____________________
    Bloody hell.
    I thought only the Victorian Govt did shit like that.
    One for your list Boerwar and your little fanboy Charles.

  15. Despite adverse polling, it would be premature to write Labor off in Queensland. Miles, who appears more relaxed absent a tie, with the earnest & loyal assistance of Dick, could be making inroads by, for instance, reducing rego & driver licence fees, among a number of other initiatives. It remains to be seen, however, whether this cunning plan will work. Viewing Crisafulli tonight, I think he has reason to be worried.

  16. Seems this is why the NDIS needs to cut services to needy people

    https://www.abc.net.au/news/2024-06-04/ndis-scam-fraud-participants-manipulated-australia/103934188?utm_source=abc_news_app&utm_medium=content_shared&utm_campaign=abc_news_app&utm_content=other

    ‘Criminals have been posing as providers to use NDIS participants’ money for organised crime.

    Funds have been spent on drugs, holidays and cars.

    What’s next? The government has put forward changes to require all providers be registered.

    Criminals manipulating participants in the National Disability Insurance Scheme have used their money to buy drugs, holidays and new cars.

    Among the instances of fraud of the $42 billion scheme were a $20,000 holiday, and a $73,000 car.

    NDIS participants have also been forced to hand over cash for criminals to buy drugs, and later harassed by the fraudulent providers.

    Officials told Senate Estimates on Monday evening courts can’t keep up with the number of cases of exploitation of participants by organised crime, with reform needed to stop manipulation of participants.

    John Dardo — integrity chief of the National Disability Insurance Agency which runs the scheme — claimed at least five per cent of the scheme’s spending wasn’t on genuine needs.

    “I have spoken to, very recently, a participant who would meet the provider at the ATM, the provider would withdraw cash and provide that cash to the participant for her to source illicit substances,” he said.

    “We have moved participants in some cases from those providers only to have the providers knocking back on their door to actually solicit them.

    “They’re coming through as a different provider, as a different entity or they’re buying different providers or they’re establishing other providers or they’re coming back as an unregistered provider, so there’s a whole series of patterns.”

    Mr Dardo said some participants have even had to be moved to different locations to escape the harassment from criminals.

    “We have had situations where we’ve involved state police in interventions where we have tried to move people away from providers that are putting participants in harm’s way.”

    NDIS Minister Bill Shorten was grilled on the fraudulent spending in Question Time, saying the issues with fraud began and worsened under the Coalition government’s 10-year-term’.

    Best to keep Bill Shorten far away from any position where he can abuse taxpayer money. After all, using well paid providers to supply services to people with disabilities is his idea.

    We know he also supports, is continuing, Morrison’s Job Provider model, where Job Providers will be given $9.5billion over 4 years. To many who are not doing their job properly, also harassing unemployed people who may have found a job on their own.

    A rather incompetent government we have now. Wasting our money on a grand scale.

    Now featuring another corrupt NDIS provider on a Current Affair.

  17. Badthinkersays:
    Tuesday, June 4, 2024 at 5:15 pm
    We’re seeing the real Andrew Giles now.
    He canceled 30 visas yesterday.
    _____________________
    Well at least he was aware of the case involving Mokbels associate who had his deportation cancelled under the Labor rule changes.
    That does show some improvement. Last week he would have blamed his Dept for not alerting him.

  18. @Mavis at 6:59pm

    That and he’s probably been informed that Friendlyjordies is now directly targeting him and his previous dodgy dealings, comparing him to John Barilaro.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VK1LGkK3w1U

    Given that one of the reasons that Barilaro quit politics was because of Jordies’ investigative works, that’s something to be nervous about.

    Also policies like reducing vehicle registration costs were popular in Victoria. I remember quite a few positive reactions to Labor’s policy of halving it for apprentices when I was doorknocking for them in 2014.

  19. ”
    Boerwarsays:
    Tuesday, June 4, 2024 at 6:12 pm
    We don’t fight wars on behalf of the ADF
    ”

    After WW2, we didn’t fight wars to defend Australia.

  20. Sprocket

    So true re Beasley. None since have either fully understood or regained control of the Defense Department.

    Marles is trying hard but Beasley started with a much better knowledge base and stayed long enough to effect change.

  21. Kirsdarke:

    Tuesday, June 4, 2024 at 7:15 pm

    Thanks for that. Crisafulli appears to have as much charismatic authority as a Weberian misfit.

  22. Irene ”Seems this is why the NDIS needs to cut services to needy people”

    Yet another example of what 104 months of Coalition neglect, incompetence, mismanagement and corruption will do. Another Augean Stable for Labor to clean out.

    ====

    Has the Coalition stumbled upon the perfect political business model? Spend their time in office looking after mates and culture warring while neglecting the actual business of governing, especially for stuff they ideologically oppose like Medicare, Social Security and the NDIS. Then, when they are eventually deservedly booted out of office, join with allies in the media and blogosphere to blame the mess on Labor.

  23. Steve777 touting the ole “we’ll need at least three decades of govt to fix it” line mixed with “we have to move very very slowly line”

    Steve777 remember the old Maoist slogan “dare to struggle dare to win”. Cast off the imprisonment of ur false consciousness Steve.

  24. Why on earth would the Dutch be desperate, or for that matter even interested, in the TLAM version, of the Tomahawk missile being placed on their new submarines?

    What they need, like Australia, is a heavy and long range Naval Strike missile. The French already have one in service on their Barracuda class submarine, and it is at least as good, probably better than the naval warfare version of the American Block V Tomahawk.

    Moreover, it is available: something that may not be the case with the American weapon, given the huge demand for it from its own defense forces and that of key allies like Australia (we have been trying to get some for years) and Britain (who have to update their existing Block IV Tomahawks to Block V standards, given that Tomahawks are nor presently made in ‘capsule’ launch modules (ie. suitable for launching via a submarine torpedo tube) – problem that has prevented the RAN being able to get some for deployment on the Collins Class subs (yet another example of how compromised procurement is to the commercial interests of American and British arms manufacturers by Fort Fumble).

    If the RAN went with the French NSM version, we’s actually some some long range naval strike missile

    identified as the number one procurement requirement by the Defence Strategic Review

    on a relevant platform

    submarines

    instead of having exactly ZERO such weapons or exactly ZERO such platforms from which they could be launched: and yet – apparently – we need to be ready for war with China within 5 years

    tick tock, that’s FOUR years now

    .

    Red Alert? You are kidding me.

  25. @Lars Von Trier at 7:45pm

    Are you seriously supporting Maoist policies? Those that killed millions unnecessarily? If so, wow.

  26. Irene:

    Tuesday, June 4, 2024 at 7:00 pm

    Your posts are far too long. In my view, you should state your case succinctly. I have to tell you, after two paras, I’m turned off.

  27. Kirsdarkesays:
    Tuesday, June 4, 2024 at 7:50 pm
    @Lars Von Trier at 7:45pm

    Are you seriously supporting Maoist policies? Those that killed millions unnecessarily? If so, wow.
    ===================================================

    Be careful, if you don’t support Lars’ cultural revolution and great leap forward. You may find yourself in the re-education camps.

  28. Repetition

    Appropriation

    Subordination

    Are the three cardinal sins of PB imo Mavis.thankfully I find u free of sin.

  29. Mavissays:
    Tuesday, June 4, 2024 at 7:57 pm
    Irene:

    Tuesday, June 4, 2024 at 7:00 pm

    Your posts are far too long. In my view, you should state your case succinctly. I have to tell you, after two paras, I’m turned off.
    ====================================================

    If your read one you have read them all. They all end the same way. Warning spoilers, Albanese did it.

  30. Kirsdarke @ #780 Tuesday, June 4th, 2024 – 7:50 pm

    @Lars Von Trier at 7:45pm

    Are you seriously supporting Maoist policies? Those that killed millions unnecessarily? If so, wow.

    Insurgent reactionaries will always fall back on insurgent doctrines in order to prosecute their stance. Look at what’s happening in America FFS.

    Seriously though, these ideologues will invoke the worst of the worst in order to analogise whatever point they can about Labor, however ridiculous or outrageous.

    But it’s sophistry, plain and simple, and should be regarded as such.

  31. Senate Republicans are warning New York judge Juan Merchan not to sentence former President Trump to prison or house arrest or take any other action that could disrupt the likely GOP nominee’s ability to campaign ahead of the November election.
    It could take months for Trump to appeal his conviction on 34 felony counts related to the falsification of business documents and legal experts don’t expect the conservative-leaning U.S. Supreme Court to intervene to help him.
    That means that Trump’s fate rests largely with Merchan, who could choose punishments ranging from prison and house arrest to probation and community service.
    Merchan, who earned favorable reviews from legal experts for his careful handling of the case, will sentence Trump on July 11, a few days before the Republican National Convention in Milwaukee.
    Republican senators acknowledge that legal experts say it would be highly unusual for Trump to receive a prison sentence for a class E felony and that he would most likely be allowed to remain free pending his appeal to higher state courts.
    But they’re nervous about what may happen because Merchan wields a lot of discretion over the terms of the sentence and they felt he tilted the trial against Trump’s team.
    https://thehill.com/homenews/senate/4701566-gop-senators-warn-judge-against-sentencing-trump-to-prison/

  32. Former Liberal staffer Bruce Lehrmann is planning to challenge findings made against him in the Federal Court on the grounds he was denied procedural fairness, attacking Justice Michael Lee’s approach to Network Ten’s truth defence.

    Mr Lehrmann has lodged an appeal against findings he did, on the balance of probabilities, rape Brittany Higgins at Parliament House in 2019.

    The findings meant his bid to sue Network Ten and journalist Lisa Wilkinson for defamation failed, because they had proved their truth defence.

    The notice of appeal filed with the Federal Court states the documents were prepared by Mr Lehrmann himself.

    https://www.abc.net.au/news/2024-06-04/bruce-lehrmann-appeal-documents-procedural-fairness-grounds/103934894

    He needs to let it go. He lost. He was humiliated. He needs to move on.

    After all, Lehrmann has other impending rape charges on his horizon. Time to focus on those IMO.

  33. Holdenhillbilly says:
    Tuesday, June 4, 2024 at 8:16 pm
    Senate Republicans are warning New York judge Juan Merchan not to sentence former President Trump to prison or house arrest or take any other action that could disrupt the likely GOP nominee’s ability to campaign ahead of the November election…

    The Republican senators are not so much “warning” the judge as threatening him gangster style.

  34. On the other hand, keep digging, Brucie, I’m sure the many more pictures and video footage of his doughy face with a beard looking like sprinkled chocolate showing up constantly to court in the media will send voters by the dozen to the true cause of the LNP, constantly fighting sexual misconduct allegations.

  35. ”The Republican senators are not so much “warning” the judge as threatening him gangster style.”

    That’s how I read it. They “warned” the judge. Don’t do it or else… what?

    They must be sailing very close to contempt of court, surely.

  36. Hey ho! I’m back in Australia, I’m over my jet lag, I’ve restocked the house with food and unpacked my bags, washed my dirty clothes and put the clean ones away! So, on with the show.

    And I see that the creatures who love to nickel and dime Labor when they are in government have crawled out from underneath their rocks again to complain about one single, solitary speech writer who Labor has employed. Big deal!

    Has anyone sought to ask Peter Dutton how much he’s paying his speech writer, just for comparison’s sake, of course? Or is his speech writer working pro bono on secondment from a Murdoch media outlet? Of course, we’ll never know the answer because the Coalition are not particularly fond of transparency, or shifting the spotlight away from Labor and towards highlighting their own hypocrisy. Like, for example, how much was Dutton’s speech writer paid when HE was a Minister?

    Just asking questions. 🙂

  37. I thought that the Republicans were in the Minority in the Senate? So, what CAN they do? Insinuate that they will be in the Majority after the election, and then they will come a’hunting judges?

  38. Welcome back, C@t.

    And yes I think people have thought to ask Dutton the Robber’s Dog that, but thought it best not to with their bosses most likely firmly banking on the LNP winning the next election, so naturally they haven’t.

  39. C@t at 9:01pm

    I thought that the Republicans were in the Minority in the Senate? So, what CAN they do? Insinuate that they will be in the Majority after the election, and then they will come a’hunting judges?

    I don’t think they can even do that with a majority of 51-49. They’d need a supermajority of 67 votes to get rid of judges, which definitely won’t happen in this round of senate elections.

  40. At $300k pa you would hope she does more than just write speeches and media releases.

    At $300k pa you’d be hoping to get the equivalent of the Gettysburg Address, the Sermon on the Mount, “I have a dream”, and “We choose to go to the moon” in the first year, followed by output of equal value in the second year.

    The people who approve this wasteful spending are incompetent. The Poll Bludger centrists who make excuses for such wasteful spending are buffoons.

  41. There was a guy (Adam Curr I think his name was) a very strong labor supporter and very involved, who years ago advocated the use of overseas people to fill the ranks of the military forces.In particular he had his sights on PNG, I don’t think the idea came from Dutton; I suspect it was floating around in Labor circles for a while.

  42. Nicholassays:
    Tuesday, June 4, 2024 at 9:13 pm
    At $300k pa you would hope she does more than just write speeches and media releases.

    At $300k pa you’d be hoping to get the equivalent of the Gettysburg Address, the Sermon on the Mount, “I have a dream”, and “We choose to go to the moon” in the first year, followed by output of equal value in the second year.
    =======================================================

    You really are under valuing those speech writers. For $200k pa you get the chancer Bruce Lehrmann looking after top secret files in your office. A speech writer must be worth more than that you would think.

Comments Page 16 of 17
1 … 15 16 17

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *