Who says what

Those who get exasperated at the deluge of opinion polling that normally accompanies election periods should be enjoying the Western Australian campaign, which has gone an astonishing 10 days without a single published poll. The drought is broken today with the Sunday Times’ second Market Equity survey for the campaign. Although its small sample of 420 is not much to go on, the results are consistent with the Poll Bludger’s expectations in that Labor leads 41.1 per cent to 38.4 per cent on the primary vote with a rough two-party split of 51-49. The paper also features what to my knowledge is the only attempt to predict individual seat outcomes other than my own, courtesy of Colleen Egan and Grahame Armstrong. The layout of the web article is hard to follow, and the contributors are indecisive in some cases, but our respective assessments basically stack up as follows:

Egan Armstrong Bludger
Albany LIBERAL GAIN LIBERAL GAIN LIBERAL GAIN
Alfred Cove Independent retain LIBERAL GAIN Independent retain
Bunbury LIBERAL GAIN LIBERAL GAIN LIBERAL GAIN
Cent. Kimb.-Pilb. LABOR GAIN LABOR GAIN LABOR GAIN
Churchlands Independent retain Independent retain Independent retain
Collie-Wellington Labor retain Labor retain Labor retain
Geraldton Labor retain Labor retain Labor retain
Girrawheen Labor retain Labor retain Labor retain
Joondalup LIBERAL GAIN LIBERAL GAIN Labor retain
Kalgoorlie Liberal retain Liberal retain Liberal retain
Kimberley Labor retain Labor retain Labor retain
Kingsley LABOR GAIN Liberal retain Liberal retain
Mindarie Labor retain Labor retain Labor retain
Murray LIBERAL GAIN LIBERAL GAIN Labor retain
Riverton LIBERAL GAIN Labor retain Labor retain
Serp.-Jarrah. Liberal retain Liberal retain Liberal retain
Swan Hills LIBERAL GAIN Labor retain Labor retain
Wanneroo LIBERAL GAIN Labor retain Labor retain
Yokine Labor retain Labor retain Labor retain

The Sunday Times article neglects to spell out for its readers what these predictions ultimately amount to, so the Poll Bludger can exclusively reveal that Armstrong is predicting a one-seat Labor majority, an outcome also allowed for by Egan who nevertheless inclines slightly towards a Coalition minority government. Peter Brent at Mumble says Labor by 11 seats; I reckon five.

UPDATE (20/2/05): The above statement about the Sunday Times article was based on the online version. The hard copy spelled out very clearly their respective predictions – ALP 29, LNP 27, IND 1 for Armstrong, LNP 28, ALP 27, IND 2 for Egan. This has enabled me to infer their predictions where only ambivalent comments were included in the article, so the "uncommitted" entries are now filled in.

Author: William Bowe

William Bowe is a Perth-based election analyst and occasional teacher of political science. His blog, The Poll Bludger, has existed in one form or another since 2004, and is one of the most heavily trafficked websites on Australian politics.