Live Commentary
9:37am Thursday I’m not sure why it’s taking so long to get final results, but with 96% of polls counted, Remain leads by 75.1-24.9, a 50.2-point margin. Three of the five final polls had Remain leading by 47 to 53 points, but the other two (Angus Reid and Mainstreet) only gave Remain a 31-32 point lead. The error in the margin of those two polls was 18-19 points, or just under half of the 1936 Literary Digest poll’s error. That’s very poor.
9:31am Wednesday With 90% of polls reporting, Remain leads by 75.2-24.8. Contrary to my previous post, there’s been some movement against Remain in later counting.
5:42pm There was an error with the polls reporting number, so actually it’s 38% of polls counted, with Remain leading by 76.5-23.5. Urban areas that overwhelmingly support Remain have been relatively slow to count, so Remain should increase further in the final results.
4:16pm Finally results from Alberta! With 42% of polls reporting, Remain leads by 76.5-23.5, a 53-point margin. The polls at the top end of Remain support will be more accurate.
3:58pm Still no results from Alberta. Canada is usually quick to report results once polls close.
2:44pm Here’s the CBC’s referendum results page. There will be a projection once enough votes have been counted.
9:35am Tuesday Owing to delays in opening some polling stations in Alberta, some will stay open until later. No results will be released until all polls are closed at 10pm local time (3pm AEDT).
Guest post by Adrian Beaumont, who joins us from time to time to provide commentary on elections internationally. Adrian is a paid election analyst for The Conversation. His work for The Conversation can be found here.
Polls close at 1pm AEDT today for a referendum on whether the right-wing province of Alberta should secede from Canada. If the referendum succeeds, there will be a binding referendum at a later date. Five polls of this referendum taken since last Tuesday gave “Remain in Canada” 31-to-53-point leads.
This referendum isn’t like the 2016 UK Brexit referendum. While most Brexit polls gave “Remain” a lead, there were polls with “Leave” ahead, and the “Remain” lead in polling aggregates was one to four points, compared with the 3.8-point official margin for “Leave”. For “Remain” to lose this referendum, the polls would need to be about as wrong as the infamous 1936 Literary Digest poll that understated Roosevelt’s popular vote margin at the 1936 US presidential election by 39 points.
At the 2025 Canadian federal election, the Conservatives defeated the centre-left Liberals in Alberta by 63.5-27.9 with 6.3% for the left-wing New Democratic Party (NDP) in Alberta. Nationally, the Liberals defeated the Conservatives by 43.8-41.3 with 6.3% NDP.
Also in Canada, the British Columbia election will occur this Saturday, with polls closing at 2pm AEDT Sunday. In analyst Éric Grenier’s aggregate, the Conservatives are winning 50 of the 93 seats on 45.4% of votes, the governing NDP 41 on 42.5% and the Greens two on 8.7%.
I previously wrote about the BC election on October 8, when the Conservatives had led by 47 seats to 44. The NDP had won a third successive term with a bare majority of 47 of the 93 seats in October 2024, but a snap election was called two years into a four-year term.
Grenier’s aggregate of federal Canadian polls gives the governing Liberals 236 of the 343 House of Commons seats on 47.3% of the vote, the Conservatives 69 on 31.8%, the separatist Quebec Bloc 21 on 6.1% (they only run in Quebec), the NDP 15 on 10.7% and the Greens two on 1.9%. Six federal by-elections have not yet been scheduled.
Election updates: Brazil, Israel and the US
The Brazilian presidential runoff election is next Sunday, with polls closing at 7am AEDT Monday. At the October 4 first round, Flávio Bolsonaro, the son of former populist right president Jair Bolsonaro, defeated Workers’ Party incumbent Lula by 47.0-45.2. Most polls of the runoff suggest a small Bolsonaro advantage of 1-2 points. There has been a narrowing in Bolsonaro’s lead from immediately after the first round.
Israel’s October 27 election will use national proportional representation with a 3.25% threshold to elect a total of 120 MPs. Only polls for the right-wing Channel 14 continue to show Benjamin Netanyahu’s right-wing governing coalition with a majority (61 seats), with all other recent polls giving the government less than 50 seats.
I covered the US November 3 midterm elections for The Conversation on Monday. In Nate Silver’s forecast model, Democrats have a 75% chance to gain control of the Senate and a 94% chance to gain control of the House of Representatives. Democrats lead Republicans by 9.6 points in the generic ballot. Donald Trump’s net approval is -22.3. There hasn’t been much change since my previous Conversation article on October 7.
Snap Spanish election called for November 29
After the defeat of housing reform legislation in early October, Spanish Socialist PM Pedro Sánchez called a snap election for November 29, about nine months before it was due. Spain uses proportional representation in multi-member electorates to elect its 350 lower house MPs.
At the July 2023 election, the conservative People’s Party (PP) won 137 seats on 33.1% of votes, the Socialists 121 on 31.7%, the populist right Vox 33 on 12.4% and the left-wing Sumar 31 on 12.3%. Regionalist parties won the remaining 28 seats, and Sánchez was able to form a government with the support of regionalists and Sumar.
Since that election, Vox has risen to about 19% in the polls, with that support coming from left-wing parties. On current polls, the PP and Vox would win a combined majority of both the votes and seats.
the ‘USA’ making a play to destroy Canada, hopefully fails.
They need to be ready for another 1812
Why do you keep saying the Canadian Liberal party is centre left when all its economic policy are centre or centre right?
Is it because it supports LGBT and climate action which are not realy leftist policies.
I would argue the Liberal Party is what it says on the tin.
It isn’t the Labour Party or the Social Democratic Party or even the Socialist Party.
NDP probably somewhat left by Canadian standards. Available in their system for people who can’t stomach voting Liberal, but in an optional voting, FPTP voting system, people who vote NDP might be allowing fascists to get elected.
Wow, just read the other 9 questions on the same ballot… they are total cooker questions. It’s like they let the sovcit brigade write them. Bit of a lapse of quality control there. So wordy too…. bad design.
There has been a secessionist movement in Alberta, apparently because they don’t like sharing their natural resource wealth with the rest of the country, a bit like the same sentiments in the Cave.
However, they obviously had a look over the border at the alternative, Chumpistan, because the Remain in Canada crowd are ascendent.
@LukeM
Each question has its own ballot paper (all differently coloured) and a separate ballot box for each question.
The putative scession question is the one that will be counted first.
Carney is the danger NOT Trump, Carney wants to take Canada for the WEF lead E.U. Have you seen the state of the E.U? its failed miserably! Now Carney wants 100 million more immigrants, the very same playbook that destroyed the E.U. Canada for the 51st state is our best play, 20 to 30% less taxes, better job prospects for the younger group, much better home prices. And for people worried about Trump as your President, he’s gone in two years…
GrannyAnnysays:
Tuesday, October 20, 2026 at 10:22 am
There has been a secessionist movement in Alberta, apparently because they don’t like sharing their natural resource wealth with the rest of the country, a bit like the same sentiments in the Cave.
********
These are pretty complex areas, and we face similar issues in Australia. In fact, the gap in gross state product per capita, or state productivity in Australia is even larger than in Canada, currently. Gross state product per capita in WA is more than double Tasmania. Both Canada and Australia have wealth equalisation mechanisms, however, with the WA GST carve out, we moved to a partial equalisation mechanism. While I don’t support the details of the WA carve out, I do support the concept of partial equalisation over trying for more complete equalisation.
Canadian elections are so boring. Australia and the US put on a good show, followed by the UK and NZ but Canada’s are always so dry in content and they don’t hyperanalyse them like we do at a booth-by-booth level.
There is still a polling station open, so counting will not have commenced yet. Authorities do not know when it will close. Just announced on https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/alberta-referendum-live-results-9.7385074
One polling station holding a whole country hostage lol
One polling station holding up the rest is on brand for these traitorous right wing separatist movements that are designed to hold the rest of the country hostage.
I would put Danielle Smith as probably the most Right-wing leader in CANZUK to the extent she probably makes Peter Dutton look moderate. I guess Australia Equivalent to Alberta would be the hypothetical Riverina state and Queensland (but with smaller Brisbane and bigger Gold Coast added being its equivalent to Edmonton and Calgary respectively) combined.
This website seems to have figures, with 20% of the count done.
Looks like remain is about 77% and secede is at 23%
Link: https://results.elections.ab.ca/8400
No discussion on CBC about the individual polling booths or comparing them to previous votes eg last election… Canada needs a massive dose of psephology STAT!
Here is the interactive map from CTV where they also have referendums about ‘Alberta wanting to control immigration’ and ‘Alberta having more autonomy from Ottawa’.
https://www.ctvnews.ca/canada/alberta-referendum/live-results/question-10/
Looks like a good result for common sense. The Remain team should remember to give special thanks to Donald Trump.
Well done to the vast majority of Albertans
Finally the guy on Global (not the CBC) mentioning that some of these results are based on 1% count in some areas… we are truly spoiled here in oz
The best referendum percentage I can see is 38.0% for the extremely rural Grande Prairie-Wapiti division. With it’s biggest town, Sexsmith, only having 2400 people in it, the next largest being Beaverlodge.
What a gigantic failure and waste of money.
Hopefully the other 9 leading questions designed by far-right conservative racists also fail miserably.
Is Europe having its Arab Spring moment? Are protests in 9 countries linked?
From France and Italy to Albania, a wave of violent protests has gripped at least nine European countries. Demonstrations, with similar grievances, have turned violent in several cities. Amid this, comparisons are being drawn with the Arab Spring, which saw the fall of several authoritarian regimes in the Middle East and Africa. What do experts say about the movements in Europe? Are they connected?
https://www.indiatoday.in/world/story/europe-arab-spring-protests-riots-france-italy-spain-albania-nine-nations-itspc-3020751-2026-10-20
“What a gigantic failure and waste of money.”
Why? I thought people on here liked democracy in action and having their say.
Danielle Smith, Premier, instigated it and she campaigned strongly for Remain so not sure why it’s a failure either – surely it’s the decisive result she was looking for to put the question to bed for a few years and focus on other stuff, after secession getting an increasing amount of coverage and murmuring.
She also picked the perfect time for it with a popular federal government and an unusual amount of anti-USA resentment even in Alberta. Not hard to see momentum going the other way if held in a different year with more conventional factors at play such as a Liberal government deeply unpopular in more conservative Alberta, and with happy relations with the USA.
It was a waste of money because the result is in line with polling, making it a completely pointless endeavour done only to appease a minority of a minority in Smith’s party to save her career.
If she had a backbone she would have told them to go jump.
Fargo61 says:
Tuesday, October 20, 2026 at 3:50 pm
There is still a polling station open, so counting will not have commenced yet. Authorities do not know when it will close. Just announced on
Ballot counting was taking place at all other locations but their results can’t be released until ALL polling stations have closed.
******************
LukeM says:
Tuesday, October 20, 2026 at 3:56 pm
One polling station holding a whole country hostage lol
Ghost Of Whitlam says:
Tuesday, October 20, 2026 at 4:05 pm
One polling station holding up the rest is on brand for these traitorous right wing separatist movements that are designed to hold the rest of the country hostage.
In response to these two comments.
Perhaps understand that different jurisdictions have different laws.
The law in Alberta is that results from any polling location cannot be released until all polling stations have closed.
No one is being held hostage. This isn’t a life and death election where the government will change immediately.
If it had passed it would have started a process and it wouldn’t have made one iota to that process if the result was declared on Monday night, Tuesday or any other day.
There was also a by-election last month in suburban Calgary. NDP gain from UCP, first time in 60 years they’ve done that. It’s one of those seats the NDP won in their 2015 breakthrough but really shouldn’t have; the top three parties all got between 30.4% and 31.3%, with the conservative vote perfectly split between PC and Wildrose. There was a bit of vote-splitting here for the “United” Conservative Party as well but nothing that extreme. Probably a good omen for next year’s election, especially if the right-wing vote keeps on fracturing (which this referendum won’t have helped).
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2026_Calgary-Shaw_provincial_by-election
“There was a bit of vote-splitting here for the “United” Conservative Party as well but nothing that extreme. ”
True but the ‘Progressive Tory’ party did get 6.11% which was bigger than NDP’s winning margin of 3.64% so could conceivably have split the vote sufficiently to change the result.
Libs also got 3.76% – they usually stand but didn’t last time.
With such a close result and a turnout of only 16k voters c.f. 25k voters last GE and electorate now of 40k voters +, I suspect that UCP will win this back when the government is at stake – unless it’s a fairly definite sweeping ‘change’ election.
New Democratic Kyle Campbell 7,461 46.63 +3.91
United Conservative Mike Derry 6,879 42.99 -13.35
Progressive Tory Kyle Joseph 978 6.11 —
Just catching up with the details of this result from late yesterday. Well done Canada and Mark Carney!
What a thrashing for the secessionists! A 75% majority is as good as you get in any genuinely free election.
Trump would never admit it, but this is a defeat for him too.
https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/swedens-centre-party-leader-explore-forming-government-2026-10-19/
After 39 days from the election with no government formed, parliamentary speaker Andreas Norlén has named Centre Party leader Elisabeth Thand Ringqvist as the next person to lead government negotiations.
This was after Social Democrats leader and one-time brief Prime Minister Magdalena Andersson had failed to secure enough parliamentary support for a second time, despite the left bloc winning 176 seats to the right bloc’s 173 because the Centre Party refuses to be in a government where the Left Party has ministerial positions.
Norlén on October 19th tasked the Centre Party’s Thand Ringqvist with exploring the conditions for a government in the middle, the alternative advocated by her party.
“It is quite reasonable that she is now given the opportunity to get to the bottom of the so-called centrist option,” Norlén told a press conference.
Thand Ringqvist is due to report back to the speaker on October 26th.
This does not mean that the Centre Party leader will be the next prime minister candidate. Norlén clarified that he had not asked her to form a government, simply to lead negotiations.
I couldn’t believe how transparent the Trump Regime and the ‘USA’ more generally have been about trying to destroy Canada.
How would they have coped if Carney had said – now we are getting to get deeply involved in Washington State or Maine politics with a view to acquiring it. Yankee-doodles would freak. Those red hats would burst into flames on those angry heads.
That said, most sensible Canadians, like the Guard the Leaf group, reject taking any ‘Americans’ in. You at least need some sort of ante-room where you can de-indoctrinate them for a few years before they come in.
You’re talking piffle, Corleone.
I have plenty of friends in both countries who are also mutual friends and the dispute between the governments has made not a jot of difference to them.
In contrast to the Carney-mania seen in Canadian polls generally, some of them are as embarrassed by Carney’s ‘playing tough’ – involving cosying up to communist, authoritarian China instead, and generally allowing the Canadian economy to suffer more in the foreseeable future – as they are annoyed by Trump, if not more so in fact. I accept that this is not – yet – a mainstream Canadian view.
But the idea that Canadians are now all rabid anti-Americans is for the birds, as it should be if you credit them with a modicum of sense and adultness.
These are the latest polls wrt the American Mid Term elections:
https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/polls/latest-polls.html?unlocked_article_code=1.K1E.-RTK.psMAF6-eYVry&smid=url-share
You’re talking piffle, Corleone.
I have plenty of friends in both countries who are also mutual friends and the dispute between the governments has made not a jot of difference to them.
In contrast to the Carney-mania seen in Canadian polls generally, some of them are as embarrassed by Carney’s ‘playing tough’ – involving cosying up to communist, authoritarian China instead, and generally allowing the Canadian economy to suffer more in the foreseeable future – as they are annoyed by Trump, if not more so in fact. I accept that this is not – yet – a mainstream Canadian view.
But the idea that Canadians are now all rabid anti-Americans is for the birds, as it should be if you credit them with a modicum of sense and adultness.
++++++++++++
Wrong.
Based on the latest GTL interview with Stephen Marche, author of the Next Civil War, have ordered the book, will review it on the main thread.
The ‘USA’ you once knew is not coming back. Methed up to the gills – the Dave Hughes of the developed world.
BC today with the conservatives in front in the polls by 5 points or so
41 to 36 for the NDP, Greens in the teens
Sounds like turnout will be well down
This BC coverage is weird, I’ve just switched to the CBC News. They are showing the number of seats where a candidate is leading rather than where they’ve won
Some of the seats have only a handful of votes
Conservatives leading in 67, NDP in 24, Greens 1 and One BC 1
Plenty of votes still to be counted CBC News has called a Conservative majority