Freshwater Strategy: 51-49 to Coalition (open thread)

Peter Dutton deemed “better placed to engage and negotiate with” a President who will make the world “less safe”.

The monthly Freshwater Strategy poll for the Financial Review (presently available online in the paper’s subscriber-only digital edition) records no change of consequence on voting intention, with the Coalition maintaining a 51-49 lead on two-party preferred, with Labor steady on the primary vote at 30%, the Coalition down one to 40% and the Greens up one to 14%. Anthony Albanese is down two on approval to 33% and up one on disapproval to 50%, while Peter Dutton is steady on 37% and up two to 41%. Albanese’s lead as preferred prime minister shifts from 44-43 to 43-42.

The poll also finds 55% believe the world will be less safe with Donald Trump as President, compared with 28% for safer, and that 47% consider Peter Dutton “better placed to engage and negotiate” with Trump, compared with 36% for Anthony Albanese. The poll was conducted Friday to Sunday from a sample of 1046.

Author: William Bowe

William Bowe is a Perth-based election analyst and occasional teacher of political science. His blog, The Poll Bludger, has existed in one form or another since 2004, and is one of the most heavily trafficked websites on Australian politics.

1,085 thoughts on “Freshwater Strategy: 51-49 to Coalition (open thread)”

Comments Page 4 of 22
1 … 3 4 5 … 22
  1. dave @ #141 Monday, November 18th, 2024 – 2:16 pm

    From what I understood Alan Jones backed Bob Carr fairly strongly at times. I have read Jonestown but it was some time ago. From my reading of the book he was vitally important to the Carr government. Or so they believed.

    It was a symbiotic relationship – Jones left Carr alone provided he did what Jones said. Some commentators have said Jones was an auxiliary member of cabinet and certainly Carr checked at least one cabinet appointments with Jones.

    Two things stand out for me in Jonestown:
    1. Jones adopting traditional Greek dress when a candidate for Earlwood
    2. The hard time Blocker Roach gave him during the short time he was the coach of the Tigers.

  2. Boerwar here with the nonsequiturs again. We’re talking about an Australian citizen who used his power and influence as a senior advisor to a foreign government to (at the very least) publicly advocate for war crimes and genocide.

  3. ‘Bean says:
    Monday, November 18, 2024 at 2:36 pm

    Boerwar here with the nonsequiturs again. …’
    ====================
    The total lack of balance is an accurate sequitur. You might not like it. But there it is. I suggest you check out what is happening in Sudan right now. You might actually be shocked.

  4. Vanuatu gets a quarter of its GDP from tourism. Silence on the air industry generating 5% of the worlds greenhouse impacts.

    Silence on China burning half the world’s coal.

    Just sticking it Australia. How easy is that?

    And P1 who is a leading advocate for the tourism industry on Bludger falls into line.
    Pathetic.

  5. https://open.substack.com/pub/tdunlop/p/flushing-out-the-augean-parliament?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android&r=3adf2s

    Tim Dunlop has some interesting, idealistic and radical I suppose, things to say about ‘the duopoly’ and that, “What is happening to Labor under Albanese is symptomatic of a political reversion to the meanness of a neoliberal centrism.”

    Fighting words for some. It would be good if people read it before telling me how wrong Tim is.

    I’ll always appreciate Tim and his road to surfdom blog.

  6. Donald Trump has nominated Big Tech critic Brendan Carr to head the Federal Communications Commission. The president-elect announced his latest high-level appointment in a statement on Sunday, calling Carr, the most senior Republican commissioner on the FCC, “a warrior for Free Speech” who would “end the regulatory onslaught that has been crippling America’s Job Creators and Innovators”.
    Carr authored a chapter in Project 2025, the controversial Heritage Foundation manifesto of radical conservative action plans for Trump if he returned to the White House. He suggested curbing the legal protections for internet publishers enshrined in Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, which shields online platforms from legal liability over content posted by their users.
    https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2024/nov/18/brendan-carr-trump-fcc-nomination-career-history

  7. Dunlop is a fool

    300,000 fee free TAFE places versus ‘waste of funding’
    S3 tax cuts for everyone versus tax cuts for the wealthy
    closing the gender pay gap versus a decade of misogyny
    27% increase in wages versus systematic wage suppression
    highest ever employment participation
    falling inflation versus double the inflation
    actual surpluses of $150 billion versus back in black Big Lie
    reduction in HECs debt versus opposition to same
    a suite of policies to promote renewables including $20 billion in funding versus nuclear brainfart
    real wages growing instead of real wages falling
    bulk billing up by 6.4 million versus systematic white-anting of bulk billing
    public service responsive to clients versus running down the APS, huge waiting lists and Robodebt
    $19 billion on housing versus promise to cut it back to zero

  8. https://bsky.app/profile/australiainstitute.org.au/post/3lb6wsx5z6c2k

    “As the world’s 3rd largest fossil fuel exporter, the Australian Govt is exporting climate destruction overseas, including to Pacific nations who experience the most devastating impacts of the crisis, despite contributing the least,”
    said Ralph Regenvanu, Vanuatu’s special envoy for climate change.

    https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2024/nov/18/australia-accused-of-exporting-climate-destruction-on-tiny-pacific-neighbours-with-massive-gas-expansion-plans

    The fossil fuel cartel own the federal Lib and Lab parliamentary majority and continue to destroy the planet and Australia’s standing in our region.

    Voters are negligent in letting it go on.

    Shame !

  9. Yes Boerwar. Its disgusting what France, the UAE and Russia have been allowed to get away with in Darfur. Instead the UAE gets away with it because of their immense wealth. They can buy anything they want in this world and we are all happy to accept it. Most rural towns (including my own hometown) in Australia has a ton of land owned by the Rashid Al Maktoum for his horses. One of the main reasons I refuse to engage with the Melbourne cup at all is because it is host to these genocidal dictators and their ridiculous hobbies.

    Unfortunately it is hard to find on the ground media in Darfur due to the lack of access to internet and media in general, but no doubt we are missing a lot of information.

  10. ‘Bean says:
    Monday, November 18, 2024 at 3:09 pm

    Yes Boerwar. Its disgusting what France, the UAE and Russia have been allowed to get away with in Darfur…’
    ================
    My point was that if charging individual Israelis with genocide then there was immense scope for stretching that initiative to a horde of nasties.
    My point is the lack of balance.

  11. Mavis says:
    Monday, November 18, 2024 at 2:01 pm

    This is a ridiculous waste of the Court’s time.

    How a Victorian Court or any Australian Court has any jurisdiction in this matter is beyond me.

  12. Boerwar @ #157 Monday, November 18th, 2024 – 2:43 pm

    And P1 who is a leading advocate for the tourism industry on Bludger falls into line.
    Pathetic.

    Complete bollocks, as usual.

    I do not advocate for the tourist industry. I advocate against the fossil fuel industry.

    Do you really not comprehend the difference? Or do you just not want anyone to do that?

  13. C@tmomma says:
    Monday, November 18, 2024 at 10:04 am
    FUBAR @ #75 Monday, November 18th, 2024 – 9:57 am

    The Victorian Education Minister has to resign or be sacked.
    Says an ultra conservative guy from WA.

    Oh, look, the Head of Department has quit instead of the Minister. Talk about an omnishambles.

  14. Boerwar
    closing the gender pay gap versus a decade of misogyny
    ————————
    Ignored royal commission’s recommendations on disability employment after decades of ableism.

  15. Vanuatu is, at scale, a disproportionate contributor to greenhouse gas emissions.
    P1 jumps in and just wallows in the hypocrisy.

  16. ‘Mexicanbeemer says:
    Monday, November 18, 2024 at 3:19 pm

    Boerwar
    closing the gender pay gap versus a decade of misogyny
    ————————
    Ignored royal commission on disability employment after decades of ableism.’
    =====================================
    One million new jobs created including for people coming off the NDIS. The NDIS reformed after a decade of decay and corruption under the Coalition. Additional spending on the NDIS.

  17. Boerwar
    =====================================
    One million new jobs created including for people coming off the NDIS. The NDIS reformed after a decade of decay and corruption under the Coalition. Additional spending on the NDIS.
    ————————————
    NDIS is not a disability employment service and labor has ignored the disability royal commission recommendations.

  18. Boerwar I see you are not engaging with the Sudan genocide. Figures that you dont actually care at all.

    And there is no stretch in prosecuting an Australian citizen for crimes against Australian law. It would be a vastly different issue if they charged the leader of a foreign country for crimes in Australian court.

  19. ‘Bean says:
    Monday, November 18, 2024 at 3:25 pm

    Boerwar I see you are not engaging with the Sudan genocide.
    ….’
    ==============
    Twaddle. I raised it today, as I have done before. For some reason the peeps who go ballistic on Israel’s utterly deplorable behaviour on the West Bank and in Gaza are totally silent on Sudan.
    There must be a reason.
    My point stands.
    There is an obvious and deplorable lack of balance afoot.

  20. Its funny when Boerwar twists himself so much he ends up advocating for Vanuatu to just shut the hell up, be poor and go sink into the ocean already. I wonder why our neighbours are disappointed with us.

    It is a cautionary tale of whataboutism

  21. ‘Bean says:
    Monday, November 18, 2024 at 3:37 pm

    Its funny when Boerwar twists himself so much he ends up advocating for Vanuatu to just shut the hell up, be poor and go sink into the ocean already. I wonder why our neighbours are disappointed with us.’
    —————
    I see that you have caught P1’s disease. My point is that Vanuatu is silent on China burning half the world’s coal. It is silent on its own disproportionate contribution to global warming. It is hypocritical. That is all. Hypocritical. I expect that it will continue to depend on the tourism industry until it sinks under the rising Pacific.

  22. And Boerwar, what Tim said about lifelong Labor voters so dissapointed with Albanese is true for me.

    You are a negative for anyone wanting to be happy voting again for Labor. I will vote for them, there is no alternative for me, rusted on, but you are not what I want Labor to be.

    You suck as a Labor advocate.

  23. ‘tripitaka says:
    Monday, November 18, 2024 at 3:31 pm

    Yea right Boerwar, so predictable. So like FUBAR you are, same aggressive, overweaning, Iauthoritian personality, always looking to tell everyone how awesome you are. Lol dude.

    Who gets to judge who is the fool?’
    ——————
    You just made a series of foolish judgements while indulging in a bit of self-evident hypocrisy about making judgements, if that helps.
    Other than that, if you have a point to make, make it.

  24. ‘tripitaka says:
    Monday, November 18, 2024 at 3:42 pm

    And Boerwar, what Tim said….’
    =================
    …yeah. I wish that Labor had entered government without a trillion dollar debt, without the systemic destruction carried out by the Coalition over ten years, without the global inflation drivers and without the massive post Covid migration catch up. In my dreams.
    Did you know that Labor’s vaccine reforms will keep around 10,000 babies a year out of hospital and about a quarter of them out of ICU?
    This is good for the babies. It is good for their families. It is good for the hospital space freed up.
    No? You did not hear about it? You certainly would not hear it from what Tim said…
    There are lots of things that Labor is doing that are not seeing the light of day. But they are good.
    Did Tim say that?
    Nope.
    Did Tim mention the $900 million spent on shingles vaccines to keep older people out of hospitals and out of GP clinics?
    No. Not what Tim said, hey.
    There are lots of things that Labor is doing that are not seeing the light of day. But they are good.
    Did Tim mention that Labor has reversed the decline in bulk billing under the Coalition and that there have been an additional 6.4 million bulk billed doctor’s visits?
    Tim did not say that? Why? No balance? What.
    Did Tim mention the 800,000 bulk billed visits to Labors 80 new emergency clinics scattered across the length and breadth of Australia? Almost certainly freeing up hospital resources?
    No? Well what is wRONg with Tim?

  25. I made my point but you, as usual missed it.

    And fire up like a berserker on a keyboard, taking on all comers. Left right and centre, vanquish them all with your awesomness.

  26. Boerwar
    There are lots of things that Labor is doing that are not seeing the light of day. But they are good.
    ———————
    LOL sounds like kid with an invisible friend they are such besties but no one can see it.

  27. ‘tripitaka says:
    Monday, November 18, 2024 at 3:50 pm

    I made my point but you, as usual missed it.

    And fire up like a berserker on a keyboard, taking on all comers. Left right and centre, vanquish them all with your awesomness.’
    =================
    If you have a point of substance to make about Tim failing to provide a balanced POV, go for it. Other than that I am rather enjoying your creative insults.

  28. Boerwar @ #183 Monday, November 18th, 2024 – 3:26 pm

    Vanuatu’s tourism industry depends on CO2 emitting cruise ships and tourists flying in and out.

    Air lines and shipping lines are accountable for their C02 emissions, not the countries they visit. How could you apportion it otherwise? The general rule applied is that those who pay for the fuel (to cover cases of chartered planes or ships) are responsible for the emissions that fuel generates. Vanuatu is only responsible for the emissions visiting tourists generate while “in country”.

    You could perhaps argue perhaps that countries should be accountable for airline emissions of their national carrier, and that the flag country should be accountable for the emissions of their registered ships. That would be a reasonable approach, albeit not one that is currently used.

    But if it was, Air Vanuatu has only five planes. I don’t know how many cruise ships are registered in Vanuatu, but it would most likely be a big fat zero. So their C02 emissions even under such a scheme would be quite small.

    This is because almost all the world’s shipping is registered to just a handful of countries – Panama, Liberia, Marshall Islands, Hong Kong, Singapore, China, Greece, Malta, Cyprus, Bahamas and Japan.

  29. BW, Vanuatu hasnt attacked anyone for clomate emissions, not China, not the US. They only made the statement about Australia because we are their neighbours, and we have failed to uphold our obligations. As a country
    in the pacific, speaking on a forum session for the pacific region, I think thats fair. We (not the US, not China) are also pushing for major gas developments that will have an impact on Vanuatu, abd I cant imagine they are happy about it

  30. Lidia Thorpe censured by the Senate over King Charles protest. 46 for (ALP, most L-NP, Lambie, Tyrrell, Roberts) 12 against (Canavan Greens, D Pocock)

  31. Alan Jones charged with 24 offences against 8 victims − 11 counts of aggravated indecent assault (victim under authority of offender), 9 counts of assault with act of indecency, 2 counts of sexually touch another person without consent and 2 counts of common assault.

  32. ‘phoenixRED says:
    Monday, November 18, 2024 at 3:56 pm

    Donald Trump Is Already Starting to Fail

    Donald Trump is planting the seeds of his own political demise. The corrupt, incompetent and extremist men and women he’s appointing to many of the most critical posts in his cabinet are direct threats to the well-being of the country, but they’re also political threats to Trump and to his populist allies.

    https://www.nytimes.com/2024/11/17/opinion/trump-kennedy-gaetz-hegseth.html‘
    ==========================
    Apart from Gina, who rather believes that Trump provides a lesson for Dutton, the Right in Australia have already started to distance Dutton from Trump… so they recognize the threats.
    Trump does not actually care what happens to his allies. They are expendable. He expends them. Just like that.
    The sole disappointment might be not getting the rules changed for another term.
    Other than that he is untouchable for the next four years.

  33. Oh Boerwar I didn’t notice that you made a point about Tim failing to provide a balanced pov. I thought you just said he is a fool.

    My point was lets consider rationally some ideas from leftwing people that might revitalise the tired old arguments we keep having.

    Chaos is going to be a thing because of Trump, maybe we lefties need a light mobile unit of ideas to keep up with the challenges to come, be more flexible not hunker down and protect the brand.

    Tim has taken the time to consider things and I don’t think it is fair or balanced to dismiss his ideas so cavalierly.

  34. Labor has been shown to be the duds they are with the opposition siding with the Greens and independents on changes to limit new University enrolments from overseas students to 270,000 in 2025.

    Labor left red-faced on international student cap as Coalition sides with Greens and independents

    https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2024/nov/18/international-student-cap-coalition-sides-with-greens-and-independents?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other

    ‘The move has been widely unpopular among the tertiary sector. Luke Sheehy, chief executive of Universities Australia, said universities were being used as a “political football” in the migration debate.

    “It beggars belief that one of our country’s biggest export industries is being treated this badly,” Sheehy said.

    “We can’t have a bright and vibrant higher education sector that delivers for all Australians without the revenue international education brings to our universities.”

    Sheehy has previously warned the changes could put 14,000 university jobs at risk.

    The ACT senator, David Pocock, accused Labor of scapegoating international students while praising the Coalition for its more sensible approach.

    “We need to have a plan for immigration and what that means for housing and pressures on infrastructure, all the other things that Australians are concerned about. But to just scapegoat international students, (it’s) such a poor way to do it,” he said.’

    We can see Labor is not prepared to fund Universities fully as they did when Minister Clare had a free University education. As did Albanese and other MPs in the parliament.

    Double standards abound with a Labor government, in this policy the Coalition, Greens and Independents are right.

    Labor needs to fund the states to build many more public housing projects (what this furore is about). But they won’t, so irresponsible when they have supported a big immigration plan since election in 2022,

    And now they want to break one of our biggest export industries.

    Maybe universities don’t donate to the Labor Party ? Obviously not.

    Compare to the fossil fuel industry, coal and gas, who do and as a thank you pay little tax, many pay none, and get their export policies approved.

    Labor duds in charge. And voters are noticing.

    The taxpayers, not big business, are those who fund all needs, the wasteful AUKUS, and including helping business make even bigger profits.

    Labor MPs have no respect or interest in the people who pay their salaries.

Comments Page 4 of 22
1 … 3 4 5 … 22

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *