The Australian brings us what is apparently the first ever Newspoll conducted over the Easter break, presumably portending weekly polling throughout the campaign. In what can only be a morale-booster for Labor after the troubled first week of its campaign, it records no change on two-party preferred, with Labor maintaining a lead of 53-47. Both major parties are down a point on the primary vote, Labor to 36% and the Coalition to 35%. The Greens are up two points to 12%, their best result since May last year, with One Nation and the United Australia Party both on 4%, respectively up one and steady.
The strains of the first week have shown on Anthony Albanese’s personal ratings, his approval rating down five to 37% and disapproval up six to 51%. Scott Morrison is respectively up one to 43% and down two to 52%, and his lead as preferred prime minister is out from 44-39 to 44-37. The poll was conducted Thursday to Sunday from a sample of 1510.
K – A_E, gotcha.
Thanks. Honestly, I think your framing of Rudd’s campaign is more nostaglia than fact. I was there too and remember thinking his economic message was mostly bullshit, based mostly on he wanted to avoid a hit job from Howard in defense of “his” surplus.
But you’ve made your point. I disagree a) there’s no economic message b) it needs to be front and centre for Labor to win. We’ll see who’s correct.
Sceptic @ #1046 Tuesday, April 19th, 2022 – 9:37 pm
10 News First Sydney
@10NewsFirstSyd
Scott Morrison says he will not let embattled Liberal candidate for Warringah Katherine Deves “be silenced” over tweets about transgender issues that some have regarded as bigoted.
Barrie Cassidy
@barriecassidy
Silenced? There wouldn’t be a political journalist in the country who would deny her an interview. She should step up and explain herself on national tv. Let’s see how it goes.
Said Scott Morrison with Stuart Robert and Ben Morton standing behind him. Says it all, really.
In the past the leftward candidate usually won the debate.
I’m having difficulty imagining Albanese can win a Sky News debate against Morrison. Booby traps will be laid against the former everywhere while the latter will get a walk in the park. I reckon Coalition are still 60%+ to form government.
poroti @ #1042 Tuesday, April 19th, 2022 – 9:35 pm
Bullshit.
There is plenty that Labor could do in government to help people cope with the cost of living:
1/ Make all forms of education and training (including early childhood education) completely free by including them in the public education systems. Increase funding to the state and territory governments so that their public schooling systems can be upgraded, expanded, and made genuinely free (no fees for parents to pay whatsoever). Cancel all outstanding student debt. Abolish fees for TAFE and university study.
2/ Make all forms of health care free by including them in the public health care systems. This would involve increased federal grants to the state and territory governments.
3/ Invest heavily in grid scale renewable electricity generation and battery storage. Make renewable electricity completely free to households.
4/ Make public transport free by funding local and state governments to upgrade and expand their public transport systems.
5/ Enact a national rent freeze until the federal government can increase the amount of new housing for first home buyers and the amount of public rental housing to the levels needed to provide everyone with secure tenure to housing. Enact a national tenancy law that massively upgrades tenants’ rights – with the right to lifelong tenancy at the centre of the reform. Hammer the theme that everybody needs housing while nobody needs to be a landlord, and base all policies related to housing, taxation, bank credit, land use, and property development on that principle. Place progressively stronger restrictions on the right to purchase investment properties. Frame the accumulation of investment properties correctly as a form of hoarding that harms the national interest.
6/ Use competition policy to dismantle cartels and reduce the price-setting power of large suppliers of essential goods and services.
7/ Invest in local capacity to manufacture electric cars on a large scale. Subsidize the purchase of electric cars until the prices fall to current prices for equivalent petrol vehicles. Ban the sale of new petrol and diesel cars from 2030 onwards.
8/ Increase all Centrelink social security payments – the Age Pension, the Disability Support Pension, Jobseeker, student allowance, carer’s allowance – to $620 per week for a single person. This would place everybody above the poverty line based on the Henderson Report methodology.
Freya Stark @ #1053 Tuesday, April 19th, 2022 – 9:41 pm
Are you American?
Bystander at 8.52pm re Katter
In recent weeks Scomo went to Katter territory and announced $5bn for a dam. Katter was furious, criticised the design, indicated the gov had misled him and said he was considering withholding support for the govt.
If – heaven forbid – we end up with a hung parliament, I don’t believe Katter is certain to support the Coalition, especially if they’re led by Morrison.
Katter gets on better with Albo. When Albo nominated for ALP leader in 2019, Katter was very positive and said “You can have a beer with Albo!”
The campaign images we’ve seen of Albo cheerfully interacting with normal people are evidence of one of his campaign weapons – interpersonal relationships.
Nicholas tl:dr How I think Labor can be a One Term government by scaring the horses silly.
L’arse: assuming that Albo blows this and ScoMo somehow manages to scrap back – and also assuming that your neo fascist mate, Aussie Cossack is unsuccessful in keeping KK out of Fowler – could she be the next Labor Leader? She seems to have the moxy:
https://twitter.com/i/status/1516328519160279041
Scott Morrison and the Liberal Party will never win the electorate of Sydney. 😆
C@t
Some have forgotten what happened at last election. Labor had a raft of policies that scared the horses silly.
Didn’t Turtle Bowen declare “Labor will govern alone or not alone!”?
LNP operatives always have free advice for how the ALP can make themselves unelectable.
https://twitter.com/theprojecttv/status/1516345037810020353?s=21&t=ystI8IVPz-buvwtkyRzWnQ
Waleed Aly chumming it up with ex Howard COS Grahame Morris over “Mediscare,” then turns on him over a half-genuine argument about trans women in sport.
Talk about out of touch in the extreme! It’s no wonder that Waleed has/had a show on RN.
Victoria @ #1061 Tuesday, April 19th, 2022 – 9:47 pm
Exactly. Just because it may be the right thing to do, doesn’t make it the smart thing to do.
Angus Taylor will not release the modelling he’s basing his scare campaign on. Labor have and The Australia Institute have this to say:
You know what usually works to help governments put in place effective reforms to services?
Having political capital to spend.
How does one collect such capital?
Win.
@jt1983:
“ But you’ve made your point. I disagree a) there’s no economic message b) it needs to be front and centre for Labor to win. We’ll see who’s correct.”
My points really are about risk management. It is possible for Albo and Labor to win without an overarching economic narrative, but THAT seems to be an extremely risky approach. The current strategy seems to rely upon Morrison being so hated that just turning up will be enough. What if it turns out that Morrison isn’t hated (even if he ain’t loved or even respected much) outside the elites inner city and inner burbs bubble? What if the punters in the key seats simply look at Labor and see nothing but static on their key issues and conclude ‘better the devein you know: at least the Liberals are better at managing money.”
Ps. I agree: Kevin07s ‘economic conservative’ line was pure Kabuki theatre. BUT it did serve a purpose. An important purpose. Albo seems as exposed as Shorten on that front, IMO.
How nany transgender women play competitive sport in Australia? Is it in the hundreds?
C@t, it’s not an entirely useless poster. Plenty of people who live in marginals work in central Sydney. Unlike say Boston where nowhere in commuting range is really in play (excepting southern New Hampshire).
Victoria @ #1069 Tuesday, April 19th, 2022 – 9:54 pm
10s?
hazza,
Two things about that interview are:
1 Waleed skewered him good and proper.
2. Why are old farts like Morriss still getting a gig?
Freya Stark @ #1070 Tuesday, April 19th, 2022 – 9:55 pm
It could be Surry Hills where a lot of people come to work.
C@t
Yeah it would be good to know.
The Herald editorial leaves nothing unsaid that needed to be said:
https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/candidate-s-distasteful-comments-are-a-stain-on-the-liberal-party-20220419-p5aeln.html
If Labor wins government next month, they need to toughen their proposed anti-corruption commission to have the power to impose serious jail time, as well as set up a commission into media bias and journalistic integrity. The media will scream “government censorship” which is all the more reason why it’s important to use up political capital on it. I don’t think the censorship line will be very effective since successive polls show mainstream journalists are trusted only a little more than bankers and used car salesmen.
Australia needs major reform if it is to successfully navigate the challenges ahead. We’re currently sailing towards the iceberg full steam ahead.
Want a perfect recipe for hate? Pick a minority that can’t defend themselves and no-one knows, and explain to everyone why they should be hated because they’re ‘taking advantage’ of some other cohort that they don’t know.
Fancy the CEO of guide dogs victoria endorsing Josh Frydenberg. Wrong on so many levels.
Dare i say, scandalous
—
Speechless. #auspol @GuideDogsVIC https://t.co/uF5lvMijTe
The bloke in the Hunter looks like he could easily beat ScoMo in an eating competition, quite possibly by eating Scomo!
Victoria,
That’s not good for the guide dog brand, people will be put off by that sort of partisan action.
Nicholas
A few days ago you gave your formula of how to entice doctors into salaried positions to boost public health.
The problem is that not only do those award positions (which you thought were ott) already exist but the awards are far more generous.
And still in many specialties it is impossible to attract specialists from private practice into salaried jobs
Chris at 10.00pm
Truly independent anti corruption commissions can’t impose any sentence on anyone.
They investigate and turn over evidence to the relevant Director of Public Prosecutions. Any judging and sentencing is, and has to be, done through the courts system.
I do, however, have a list of public figures who, IMHO, could do with some jail time…
On Insiders, three days ago, Hartcher, Probyn and Maiden all agreed Albanese’s “gaffe” could be a pivotal moment in the Federal election. They’re all good journos, but seem prone to hyperbole based on the thinnest of evidence. Locked in the moment, seduced by the sexy, the search for the mystical all conquering ‘gaffe’ that will somehow swing a nation’s political history. Immune to the broader sweep of consistent polling showing a government on the nose.
But hey ho all three will be up again soon with some compelling analysis of why either leader is now ‘on the nose’. And I’ll hazard a guess none will repeat their analysis of the ‘gaffe’.
Thunder, wind, lightning and heavy rain in Sydney after a 5-day “mini drought” over Easter.
South
Not good. I have sent them an email letting them know.
Ugh, a moment of weakness causes me to venture down the “View Comments” rabbit hole once more, and as usual, the Complacency Trolls don’t disappoint.
As a whole, I’d say I disagree with a touch over 50% of the opinions that Andrew Earlwood expresses in these threads, but violate me in the ear with a backfiring hedge-trimmer if he hasn’t perfectly articulated my incredulity and frustration at the ALP’s perennial insistence on meekly accepting as utterly incontestable and axiomatic the Coalition’s assertions of being superior economic managers.
The Complacency Trolls genuinely expect the rest of us to believe it to be but mere coincidence that the ONE election that Labor has won in almost 30 years – only ONE out of the past nine (quite possibly soon to be ten), for Gough’s sake* – also just so happened to be the only one at which Labor’s campaign machine actually bothered to tackle head-on the falsehoods regarding their ability to manage money.
As our esteemed moderator himself said during the 2010 campaign: “They have a good story to tell on the economy, but it never occurred to me that they wouldn’t bother telling it”. (Tut tut, William, you bed-wetting, concern-trolling LNP operative, you.) And more than a decade later, here we are, still stuck in this very same rut.
Yeah, Labor still have just over a month to start standing up for themselves against these falsehoods – to run a 2007-style campaign as opposed to a 2019-style one – but the trouble is that they evidently have no intention whatsoever of doing so, if the typically asinine ad hominem responses to Andrew in here are any indication.
The willingness to attack Andrew for what I can only consider to be displaying the very plainest of common sense, while turning a blind eye to, or even condoning, the outrageous tinfoil-hattery of Schrodinger’s Cat and “Meguire” Scott**, does more to kill my optimism about this election’s outcome than a hundred bad polls could ever do.
*Seriously, people, NINE FREAKING LOSSES OUT OF TEN. ONE FREAKING WIN IN THIRTY YEARS. You find me a successful workplace where a track record of that nature would satisfy the KPIs for a single one of the employees. No, that employee would quite rightly be given their marching orders, if only because it would be abundantly clear by that point that their heart wasn’t in their work and they had absolutely no desire to pick up their act.
**Yes, yes, Scott, I know: “lol itsthevibe”
Vic,
The explanation will be she is personally supporting a person and not the Party.
There is no Liberal Party signage.
GG
I dont think that is going to fly quite frankly.
A disturbance in the Force… tomorrows West Australian..
The West’ralian is going to be deeply conflicted with this.
But – it’s an interesting move.
Itsthevibe,
See you in 2030. Maybe you’ll feel better by then.
”
Rossmoresays:
Tuesday, April 19, 2022 at 10:05 pm
On Insiders, three days ago, Hartcher, Probyn and Maiden all agreed Albanese’s “gaffe” could be a pivotal moment in the Federal election. They’re all good journos, but seem prone to hyperbole based on the thinnest of evidence. Locked in the moment, seduced by the sexy, the search for the mystical all conquering ‘gaffe’ that will somehow swing a nation’s political history. Immune to the broader sweep of consistent polling showing a government on the nose.
But hey ho all three will be up again soon with some compelling analysis of why either leader is now ‘on the nose’. And I’ll hazard a guess none will repeat their analysis of the ‘gaffe’.
”
No matter how many times these so called ‘experts’, ‘commentators’ and ‘Influencers’ get it wrong they will be called to discuss same/ another issue on these TV shows and/or write about them in Newspapers and magazines. They will get their fat cheques from these writings and talking whether they turn out to be right or wrong.
And believe me this is not a Australian phenomenon. It happens in every democratic country whether it is US, UK, India, France and so on and so forth, the consequences of which are that people are losing faith in our Institutions, politicians and political processes and systems and we are not served well because of that and the vicious circle continues.
The nature of public health care isn’t static – it can be modified – and so can health care practitioners’ perceptions of the appeal of working in public health care. Building up the capabilities of the public health care systems over time, increasing the range and volume and quality of services that they provide, improving the practice of multi-disciplinary shared care, etc can create a self-fulfilling momentum in favour of more private practitioners joining its ranks. I work in a multi-disciplinary team in Queensland’s public mental health care system. I get to work alongside excellent medical, allied health, and peer practitioners. One is the eminent psychiatrist Manaan Kar Ray, one of the world’s foremost experts in the field of suicide prevention. He is one of many high-flying practitioners I know who choose to work in the public system – and that is despite its current significant limitations. Imagine what would be possible if its capabilities were upgraded.
C@tmomma says:
Tuesday, April 19, 2022 at 9:42 pm
poroti @ #1042 Tuesday, April 19th, 2022 – 9:35 pm
C@t
of the Labor faith
There’s ya problem. You think of it as a religion. So it’s ‘death to the infidels and heretics’ eh .
Bullshit”
————————
Never let a stranger into your house, into your cab or into your heart. Unless that stranger is a friend of Labor. And if that stranger is a friend of Labor he is the only friend you got”.
Albo will officially launch the Labor campaign in Perth on May 1 . It will be the first time any party has launched a federal campaign in the west.
https://twitter.com/lanai_scarr/status/1516389681352802307
An idea … Abbott endorsed Deves because he hated Morrison..I wonder?
I do you agree with AE that there should be over-arching economic narrative (as Keating said in his earlier musings) that public can latch on to. And it can be woven by telling how they will reduce cost of living by renewal energy, Aged care and Child care policies. Hence reassuring people that although interest rates will rise they will keep downward pressure on pressure on cost of living.
Great move to launch in WA. Very smart.
SfM may try Brisbane (or Warringah)
Went to Rudds’ launch in Brisbane in 2007.
Was a great feeling. Plenty of Tory freaks outside to rain pox on. Some Greenies too.
All in all good a good day and worth the effort.
Mick,
It’s not 7 dimensional chess.
Look at the polls. Look at the feel of the day.
Everything else will take care of itself.
”
Upnorthsays:
Tuesday, April 19, 2022 at 10:34 pm
C@tmomma says:
Tuesday, April 19, 2022 at 9:42 pm
poroti @ #1042 Tuesday, April 19th, 2022 – 9:35 pm
C@t
of the Labor faith
There’s ya problem. You think of it as a religion. So it’s ‘death to the infidels and heretics’ eh .
Bullshit”
————————
Never let a stranger into your house, into your cab or into your heart. Unless that stranger is a friend of Labor. And if that stranger is a friend of Labor he is the only friend you got”
”
That is crazy. If you don’t want to “stranger into your house, into your cab or into your heart” that is your prerogative. If that stranger knows your weakness of allowing strangers who is a friend of Labor, then that stranger will exploit your weakness to gain access into your home, cab or heart and rob you blind or even kill you if the stranger is evil.
For what ever it is worth don’t ever make Labor a cult.