The BludgerTrack poll aggregate is drifting back towards the Coalition as other pollsters fail to replicate their particularly bad result from ReachTEL a fortnight ago. There is no change on the seat projection, though this is due to the correction of an error that short-changed Labor two seats in Queensland last week. The is balanced by Coalition gains of one seat apiece in New South Wales and Victoria. Newspoll’s latest numbers have taken a big chunk out of Malcolm Turnbull’s readings on the leadership trends, while Bill Shorten holds even on net approval. Enjoy all the results in detail by clicking on the image below.
Note that there’s a post below this one on Newspoll’s latest state voting intention result from Victoria.
imacca @ #2287 Monday, March 12th, 2018 – 1:07 pm
I have always thought his greatest attribute was his implacable opposition to the Nazis and Hitler when so many in the British Establishment wanted an accommodation with Hitler. And the way his defiance stiffened the resolve of the British people.
There was an interesting little 8 part drama series on ABC TV a while back “The Halcyon” set in a posh hotel in London which portrayed some of the attitudes of the British upper class and their flirtation with the Nazis.
Dan Gulberry @ #2292 Monday, March 12th, 2018 – 1:21 pm
It is also difficult to determine just how big that croc was. It may not have been particularly large.
“I have always thought his greatest attribute was his implacable opposition to the Nazis and Hitler when so many in the British Establishment wanted an accommodation with Hitler. ”
Agreed. A prick, but a uniquely useful prick at the time and in the circumstances. Him getting dumped as PM at the end of the war probably shows that the British people had cottoned on to that. 🙂
P1
I am very aware of all the arguments. I used to believe most of the points you make. I don’t anymore.
1. As noted above farming relies less and less on biodiversity. In fact never in the history of the world has so much high quality food been produced by extremely low biodiversity farming systems.
2. These systems do depend on certain conditions being maintained. The first is genetic diversity of crop plants. While decreases in wild genetic diversity have to be offset with gene storage systems, GMO technologies totally alter the diversity equation. It will not be long before systematic improvements in food crops for straight nutrition (higher available proteins, for example) move to systematic improvements in health components as well.
3. In all current systems of food production the balance between wild caught and wild grown food and low-biodversity production agriculture has been shifting at (geologically) astronomic rates. Existing technical limits have never been less constraining. The prospect for further technical advances are virtually limitless.
4. Using the Irish blight as an example of what might go wrong is a bit of a spud murphy furphy. These days the blight would have been sprayed out of existence long before it caused a million deaths.
bemused
It looks smallish.
‘imacca says:
Monday, March 12, 2018 at 1:27 pm
“there are no hard and fast reasons why this trend should not increase.”
One episode of serious disease in zero diversity food crops will be reason enough. ‘
Serious disease in all food production systems is the norm, not the exception. What has changed is our technical ability to respond effectively.
imacca @ #2294 Monday, March 12th, 2018 – 1:25 pm
Delaying until 1943 also gave the Germans more time to prepare the Atlantic wall, making it a harder target.
The invasion of Europe was all about logistics.
Could the allies land men and equipment and supply them at a greater rate than the Germans could bring up reinforcements?
An excellent book on the topic is “The Struggle For Europe” by Chester Wilmot, an Australian journalist. Written a long time ago now, first published in 1952, but has stood the test of time.
Amazon Review.
Player One @ #2296 Monday, March 12th, 2018 – 1:26 pm
Ignorant comment of the month, and leading contender for stupidest comment of the year.
No wonder you are aghast, P1.
bemused
I’m glad that someone understands that. As a child, living in Plymouth, terrified of the bombers overhead, the warning sirens and the bombs falling, hearing Big Ben striking and then Churchill on the 9 o’oclock news was one of the few stable things in a terrifying world.
(Sometimes I feel such a stranger on PB, with the constant put-downs of ‘whiteys’ and poms.)
Boerwar @ #2305 Monday, March 12th, 2018 – 1:40 pm
I thought so too. But nothing you could use to effectively estimate the size.
Hi Player One, do you have a link to analysis that shows the implied 2050 population targets of LNP policies, of Labor policies, and of Greens policies? I remember you posting something about that in a previous thread.
Was going to post the link from The Conversation as well P1, but noticed you had already done so.
However, what do scientists from the CSIRO know compared to PB’s resident seer and Green Party obsessive, BW?
Boerwar @ #2304 Monday, March 12th, 2018 – 1:40 pm
Fortunately for the rest of us, your belief or disbelief does not matter. I provided the links for your own edification, not because I think your arguments are worth refuting.
The scientific consensus is that the loss of biodiversity we are currently experiencing is potentially as dangerous as global warming – we should certainly not be working to exacerbate it.
In fact, biodiversity loss is possibly worse than global warming because there is a chance that with sufficient biodiversity something might survive should warming reach extreme levels. Without such biodiversity, Earth could end up populated by nothing much more advanced that bacteria.
lizzie @ #2309 Monday, March 12th, 2018 – 1:50 pm
Yes, a few Anglophobes here.
You couldn’t get much further politically from Churchill than my father, but he always acknowledged Churchill’s importance.
You must be a bit older than I had previously thought if you went through WWII as a child.
I was born post WWII so can’t match your personal memories. I only have the experiences and memories passed on to me by my father and, to a lesser extent, my mother.
Plus a lot of reading inspired by what I heard from them.
Border Force at work:
http://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-03-12/asylum-seeker-family-removed-at-dawn-biloela-central-qld/9538368
Mungo explains the Trump tariff exemption and Turnbull’s latest good Government starts now announcement.
So yet again we are searching for a reset, a circuit-breaker, just something that works. But it looks as if we are facing more of the same: brutal and ruthless personal attacks on Bill Shorten, now extending to his family, staff and acquaintances, and more innumerate waffle about the wonder and beauty of corporate tax cuts.
Repeated experiments have shown that the voters are not impressed; they would probably prefer a few more verses of The Ballad Of Bonking Barnaby, as this endless soapie meanders into ever more bizarre trails. And the commentariat apparently believes that the answer is more conservative (meaning, in many cases, reactionary) ideology, a conclave of philosopher kings (themselves, naturally) to revive the heart and soul of what they laughingly call the centre-right – the time when the coalition ruled unchallenged and the voters knew their place.
https://www.echo.net.au/2018/03/thus-spake-mungo-turnbull-turns-trick-trumps-tariffs/#.WqXoKI0H4yc.twitter
Boerwar @ #2306 Monday, March 12th, 2018 – 1:42 pm
Yes, because of massive overuse of antibiotics in food production, which couldn’t possibly be bad for anyone … oh, wait … http://fortune.com/2017/11/09/antibiotic-resistance-superbugs/
Luckily, reducing biodiversity couldn’t possibly affect the development of new antibiotics … oh, wait … https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Production_of_antibiotics
lizzie says: Monday, March 12, 2018 at 1:50 pm
bemused
I’m glad that someone understands that. As a child, living in Plymouth, terrified of the bombers overhead, the warning sirens and the bombs falling, hearing Big Ben striking and then Churchill on the 9 o’oclock news was one of the few stable things in a terrifying world.
*******************************************************
My mum, who lived through the blitz like you Lizzie, said the same thing – I remember her words – ” he may well have been a drunken old hound but his speeches gave us hope when all seemed lost ” …… and indeed after the loss of soldiers and vast amounts of equipment at Dunkirk all that stood against Hitler were Churchill’s oratory and a small band of brave pilots and 2 incredible aeroplanes in the Hurricane and the Spitfire and a chain home radar system that gave them advance warnings enough to get them into the air in time.
I am sure Churchill had many faults and did many unconshionable things before and during WW2 for which he has been judged accordingly ….. but he did help prevent Hitler taking over Europe when it mattered
Nicholas @ #2311 Monday, March 12th, 2018 – 1:51 pm
Yes, I did. From memory, the result was something like this:
Science Party: 45 million.
LNP: 40-45 million
Greens: 35-40 million
Labor 30-35 million
Sustainable Australia: 26-30 million
I’ll have to try and find the post again to get all the source links from which I derived the numbers.
bemused
I was born during the war, so I can’t say I remember all of it, but there is a photo of me as a toddler standing beside an air raid shelter in the garden, and I remember hiding with my grandmother in a cupboard under the stairs at the time when a bomb fell next door. I was traumatised enough by the bombers that I was 30 years old before I could remain calm when a plane flew directly overhead, as I always waited for the crash as it fell out of the sky (and I was in Australia by then!)
What is that? Is Turnbull taking all the credit for the tariff exemption?
Did he mention anything about the decades of obsequiousness often soaked in blood? I am sure he did. Not even Turnbull can be that full of himself.
Good overview of the progress China is making in reducing emissions.
https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2018-china-pollution/
Australia’s population will reach 25 million on or about August 3 this year, adding up the numbers here: http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/abs%40.nsf/94713ad445ff1425ca25682000192af2/1647509ef7e25faaca2568a900154b63?OpenDocument
It seems that the Herald Sun and VicLib don’t like firefighters standing up for their own safety. There has been a running narrative by EBA in rebuttal of the H-Sun’s attacks, which also affected the results of the last election.
:large
Crikey:
Dutton and Hunt? Heaven forbid.
So Turnbull is siding with Trump on tariffs in opposition to Europe (and China?). This could backfire badly on ‘He of no Judgement”.
lizzie @ #2321 Monday, March 12th, 2018 – 2:16 pm
The southern part of Australia was spared direct experience of the war apart from the Jap midget subs in Sydney Harbour and a few shells fired from the deck gun of a Jap sub into the Eastern Suburbs. There were also quite a few ships sunk all around the coast of Australia by subs.
The only casualty in the extended family was an uncle of my mother who was accidentally killed by friendly fire in the round-up of the Japanese escapees from Cowra.
Father served in the RAAF and an uncle in the RAN.
Who wrote that shit?
‘Quiet achiever’ indeed. A nice little CPG beloved cliche which means nothing more than that the person in question is a LNP minister and has done SFA but avoided any major controversy.
If it was an ALP minister the word used would most likely be failure.
Hi All,
Infrequent poster over the past 1o+ years. I definitely don’t mean this as a criticism – just a request.
My daughter has taught special needs kids dance since she was 13. In the past I used to use the suffix “tard” as an insult. The first time she heard me use the term she took offence, and educated me that the use of “tard” as a suffix insult is really hurtful to friends and family of, and people who are, special needs.
Again – not meant as a criticism to anyone, as I am definitely guilty of this in the past.
Whinge whinge whinge…
http://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-03-12/womadelaide-asthma-warning-feathers-dust-pollen/9538228
Any asthmatic going to an outdoor festival in the dry months should be fully aware to be uptodate with their preventer medication, bring their emergency medication and take antihistamines before they come.
By far the worst culprit in Botanic Park is the plane trees. Dont blame it on the feathers/good times/boogie.
28th Newspoll Debt and LNP after focusing on Terrorists, Boats, Refugees, now back to union bashing:
http://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-03-12/union-boss-spent-$440k-on-corporate-credit-card-court-told/9538806
Greensborough Growler @ #2323 Monday, March 12th, 2018 – 2:24 pm
Hmmm. China’s emissions have stabilized at merely twice those of the next highest emitter (the US), and only five times as much as the next highest (India). I guess that is progress of a sort – it is certainly much better than our own laughably feeble efforts 🙁
Note: If anyone thinks it is a mere coincidence that China’s LNG imports have risen to record levels at the same time, I would point out that this now makes four of the world’s biggest economies economies – US, UK, Germany, China – who have successfully used LNG as a transition fuel. Only Australia seems to be stupid enough to continue to burn coal instead** 🙁
** Oh, and Germany – they used LNG to transition from nuclear to coal. Because Greens prefer coal to nuclear. I am not sure if that means they are stupider than we are or not.
SK, I know when I have driven past a plane tree, my throat starts to constrict. They should be outlawed as they are a public menace.
adrian
It was Michael Sainsbury
“Freelance correspondent in Asia and Little Red Blog Editor ”
Calling Greg Hunt “quiet achiever” is, to my mind, glossing over his sneaky, almost treasonous behaviour wrt Climate change, when he invented “Direct Action” (in a weekend) in order to gain himself a Ministry with Abbott.
PeeBee
Indeed. They look good for about 1 month in the year. The rest of the time they clog the drains, constrict the throat or look just plain ratty.
Not that I am the whinging type 😉
Is that Nicholas and bakunin behind Bhathal and Di Natale? 😉
Children of the revolution?
But I am all for it. What I really want to know where RDN got his jacket/shirt combo from? Most dashing.
C@tmomma @ #2337 Monday, March 12th, 2018 – 2:49 pm
I don’t think so. For some reason I always picture Nicholas wearing a propeller beanie …
https://www.buzzfeed.com/paulfarrell/peter-duttons-new-super-department-is-facing-unprecedented?utm_term=.nmmwp5Q91#.sdrekEQVd
P1
Maybe this?
Thanks Player One. It is interesting that the Science Party’s policies would result in the highest population by 2050 (45 million). You’d think that a science-based party would be highly conscious of ecological constraints. Also interesting that Greens policies would lead to a higher population (35-40 million) than Labor’s (30-35 million).
The Sustainable Population Australia website says:
https://population.org.au/about-population/australias-population
That suggests that Labor’s policy is to change the existing policy settings (related to the net overseas migration level and the domestic fertility rate) to bring about a 2050 population that is lower than 40 million. And that Greens policy is to keep existing policy settings in place and stay on course for 40 million by 2050. And LNP policy is to change the policy settings to bring about a population that is higher than 40 million.
Greens: status quo (stay on track for 40 million by 2050)
Labor: change (downwards a bit)
LNP: change (upwards a bit)
Science Party: change (upwards a bit)
Sustainable Australia Party: change (downwards a lot)
Is that correct?
lizzie @ #2335 Monday, March 12th, 2018 – 2:45 pm
Yes, lizzie.
IMHO Crikey seems to be doing less and less to distinguish itself from the rest of the CPG herd.
Not a great business model I would have thought, but what do I know.
Call them G Troop!
I just want to know who their version of the sharpshooter Wrangler Jane is.
Trump privately trashes Rick Saccone
There’s a reason Trump said hardly anything about Republican candidate Rick Saccone during a rally in Pennsylvania on Saturday night that was supposed to promote his candidacy.
•The reason: Trump thinks Saccone is a terrible, “weak” candidate, according to four sources who’ve spoken to the president about him.
March 13 special election
https://www.axios.com/scoop-trump-privately-trashes-rick-saccone-1520806446-c7033bad-f7a4-4d92-80a7-40113967a0e2.html
lizzie
Sadly that effort by Kermit the Quiet Little Achiever is classed by the Coalition as a real ‘achievement’ and worthy of praise. Especially from the party donor spivs who rorted the scheme.
Simon Katich @ #2338 Monday, March 12th, 2018 – 2:56 pm
The Hemp Clothing Store?
Fact-checking Trump’s approval ratings tweet
President Trump tweeted that media reports that his approval ratings are lower than those of President Obama are “fake news.” Here are the facts:
Donald J. Trump @realDonaldTrump
Rasmussen and others have my approval ratings at around 50%, which is higher than Obama, and yet the political pundits love saying my approval ratings are “somewhat low.” They know they are lying when they say it. Turn off the show – FAKE NEWS!
RealClearPolitics’ polling average places Trump’s approval at 40.9%, significantly lower than Obama’s approval (48.5%) at the same time during his presidency.
•Rasmussen Reports’ latest numbers, from Friday, put Trump’s approval rating at 44% — not “around 50%.”
https://www.axios.com/fact-checking-trump-tweet-about-job-approval-ratings-1520783874-4ef47401-e44a-43d2-9978-558a72b24ebb.html
GRundle in Crikey saying Alex Bhathal isn’t a bully, just ‘forthright’ in telling you when you’re wrong and she is right!
Then he puts a disclaimer at the end of his piece saying he shared a house with her for 3 years in the 80s!
No wonder he is such a stout defender/apologist for The Greens.
Nicholas @ #2342 Monday, March 12th, 2018 – 3:02 pm
Sounds about right. The Science Party (!) and Sustainable Australia have specific target numbers, but the others don’t, so you have to try and assess the impact of the parties policies on our current immigration and birth rates. I assumed the LNP would keep migration at its current record highs, the Greens would lower the skilled migration rate but increase the refugee intake, and Labor would lower both. This was based on my interpretation of their actual policies. The LNP also has policies designed to increase local fertility, but these have only a very modest effect – by far the largest growth is from our overseas intake in all cases.