BludgerTrack: 53.4-46.6 to Labor

Yet another quiet week for the BludgerTrack poll aggregation trend.

I don’t have full numbers yet from the ReachTEL poll, so the only addition to BludgerTrack this week is your usual weekly Essential Research result. This has made next to no difference on voting intention, and none at all on the seat projection. There were also no new numbers for the leadership trends this week.

Author: William Bowe

William Bowe is a Perth-based election analyst and occasional teacher of political science. His blog, The Poll Bludger, has existed in one form or another since 2004, and is one of the most heavily trafficked websites on Australian politics.

444 thoughts on “BludgerTrack: 53.4-46.6 to Labor”

Comments Page 7 of 9
1 … 6 7 8 9
  1. RM
    I imagine, because I don’t know, that there were a number of reasons. One of them was that, despite three months warning, they were caught with their pants down and were under time pressure.

    But the real reason, IMO, is Scullion.

    His record of sleazery is not well known nationally but there would have been daily ‘scoops’ of big fat dollops of some fairly ordinary behaviour.

    A pity, really… an opportunity missed. Nige would have been the first resident Territorian to lead the nation.

  2. Cotmomma – lawyers don’t “win” cases. The facts and the witnesses win cases. Though, sometimes lawyers “lose” cases!. Spycatcher was decided by a great equity judge, the court of appeal and the high court. They didn’t need Malcolm’s blathering and posturing.

  3. sprocket_ @ #286 Sunday, October 29th, 2017 – 5:42 pm

    C@t

    Yes, Savva is in Turnbull’s camp. But appears to be getting less columns in the SmearStralian. Only noticed one this week

    Thanks, sprocket. Savva has been less of a presence on the Insiders couch as well recently.

    I also note, wrt to Insiders, that the Labor Opposition are getting more interview spots and those interviews by Barrie are less combative and more respectful.

    While I’m at it I also predict that our next federal election will be in February 2019. Turnbull will want to hang on as long as possible to the golden ring he is grasping for dear life and hoping the Kill Bill strategy will finally bite in the electorate.

    I don’t think he’ll give a hoot about Gladys Berejiklian having to face the people in NSW in March 2019.

  4. BW
    And you can bet that the Nats put up their case that Nigel should be appointed DPM and be Acting PM. It comes down to Turnbull telling them to naff off, you broke it, you don’t get a prize for stuffing up.

  5. It says a lot about Turnbull’s character that the HC decision caught him unprepared.

    Just as every politician is advised to write two speeches – the acceptance one, and the one in case of defeat – no matter how unlikely losing might seem at the time, a government should be prepared for a variety of scenarios.

    Losing the two senior Nationals was always a possibility, one the government should have planned for.

    That it seems to have taken Turnbull by complete surprise suggests he never for a second contemplated an outcome that wasn’t the one he’d already decided on.

  6. Trog Sorrenson

    P1
    I think it is quite clear that you are an idiot.

    P1 does not follow the norms of civilised debate. P1 changes the subject, replies with non sequiturs, and is a waste of time to engage with.

    You think ‘Surely P1 realises that this is simply a poor argument’ and explain patiently why this is so – but no, the obfuscations, the straw men, the ‘go back and read the article again’ ploy instead of answering the question are P1’s stock in trade.

    I feel sorry for P1.

  7. I also note, wrt to Insiders, that the Labor Opposition are getting more interview spots

    I’ve noticed that too. And I believe Savva is married to one of Turnbull’s senior staff.

  8. Bw

    Nige … the vision of an acting PM with a sugar bag in one hand and couple of rusty rabbit traps hanging over his shoulder appeals.

  9. daretotread
    Briefly

    Comment 154

    Are you seriously suggesting the US status as reserve currency is not under pressure?

    Is there any suggestion that it is?

    Do you not think that the reality of allowing the yuan into the current basket even if at 10% was not a significant (not overwhelming reality?

    Anyone can hold anything they like as a reserve. They can hold used truck tyres if they choose. They can hold Yuan, but because its convertibility is impaired, most economic agents do not hold many Yuan.

    Do you not think that the mere fact that the agreement of the big gas producer and the manufacturer to exchange goods in yuan/gold will not have the effect of lowering demand for US currency?

    This is irrelevant. The Oil/Yuan/Gold coupon simply establishes a price for oil that is derived from the gold price. So what! Oil is already convertible to gold. This device illustrates the weak convertibility/liquidity of Yuan: oil suppliers will accept Yuan only if the Yuan are convertible into something else, in this case gold. Since gold is denominated for most purposes in USD, this device simply creates new arbitrage opportunities. It creates new trading instruments in Shanghai and HK. Big deal. It does not create a free and unlimited market for Yuan. On the contrary, it limits the appeal of Yuan to the amount of gold held. This is very retrograde.

    You can argue about the size of the effect but not of the effect in itself. It seems pretty bloody obvious that demand would fall somewhere in the 5-10%region.

    What matters is whether a currency is negotiable/exchangeable….whether the market is relatively liquid or illiquid. For all practical purposes, the USD market has unlimited liquidity. This is what determines Dollar-acceptability. “Demand” is no more measurable or mutable than “Supply”, which are both moderated by “Velocity”.

    It is a big what if as yet, but what if Saudi *as well as Iran) decided to trade with China, and BRICS nations in yuan not US$. This certainly would affect demand for $US

    So what! This will change nothing much. Most of the world’s economic activity is already settled in non-Dollars.

    Now as the the effect of this fall in demand, that is where I am open to persuasion ie I am not at all sure what would happen.

    Dollar use for the settlement of trade transactions makes no difference to dollars actually in circulation. This number is determined by the amount of dollar-denominated debt issued.

    More widely, we should all hope that the attempt by China to base its currency on gold at all will fail. The use of gold as a monetary unit is highly distortionary. The hoarding of gold is deflationary. It is depression-inducing.

  10. Zoomster – do you think the decision caught him by surprise? Maybe he’s such a narcissist he thought the HC would bend to his will. But even Barnyard expected it to go against him. I think Malcolm knew it would go bad. But he just lied to keep Barnyard in Cabinet. The man is a total spiv and conman. He will say and do anything to keep his circus on the road, believing that, when he’s caught out, he will throw more dust in everyone’s eyes. Malcolm will ALWAYS take the low road and, if there isn’t one, blaze it himself.

  11. antonbruckner11 @ #313 Sunday, October 29th, 2017 – 6:07 pm

    Zoomster – do you think the decision caught him by surprise? Maybe he’s such a narcissist he thought the HC would bend to his will. But even Barnyard expected it to go against him. I think Malcolm knew it would go bad. But he just lied to keep Barnyard in Cabinet. The man is a total spiv and conman. He will say and do anything to keep his circus on the road, believing that, when he’s caught out, he will throw more dust in everyone’s eyes. Malcolm will ALWAYS take the low road and, if there isn’t one, blaze it himself.

    Yep this.

    He just needed to say what he said to make it to the next day’s fuck up.

  12. anton

    If it didn’t, he wouldn’t have had to delay his trip, or wait to sort out who was going to Act while he was gone.

    Surely any vaguely sane person (let alone government) would have gamed the various possible HC decisions and have set up the scenarios for each one.

  13. https://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/politics/federal/high-court-ruling-sparks-changing-climate-in-queensland-s-senate-ranks-20171027-p4ywop.html

    High Court ruling sparks changing climate in Queensland’s Senate ranks
    By Cameron Atfield & Tony Moore
    28 October 2017 – 02:33am

    The Australian Parliament’s most high-profile climate change sceptic appears set to be replaced in the Senate by a man who once made his living warning of the dangers of climate change.
    One Nation senator Malcolm Roberts was one of five MPs declared ineligible to stand for Parliament under section 44 of the constitution in a High Court decision on Friday, as he had never formally renounced his British citizenship.
    The court also ruled against fellow former Queensland senator Larissa Waters, who resigned in July upon discovering her Canadian dual citizenship, but ruled in favour of LNP senator Matt Canavan, who sits in the Nationals’ party room in Canberra.
    Former Democrats leader Andrew Bartlett appears certain to replace Ms Waters in the Senate, while Sunshine Coast man Fraser Anning is set to replace Mr Roberts based on a countback of votes cast in the 2016 federal election.
    Mr Anning, who once ran the Sunshine Coast solar installation business Pacific Solar and Heating, once warned of the dangers of climate change in a Sunshine Coast Seniors newspaper advertorial.

  14. A reminder for those that have forgotten the “Block” function on this blog. The unedifying promotion of coal and gas by a person who refuses to acknowledge reality, more than a little like Malcolm Roberts, but less entertaining.
    I see the responses to the usual crap from this poster but not the original bullcrap and am happy to have used the block function.

  15. don

    The energy debate is as important as it is complex.
    Many have made significant contributions, even if we don’t agree on all aspects. e.g. I don’t agree with a lot of LU’s centralised network view of the world, but at least he comes to the debate with expertise and some facts.

  16. Some folks thought I was using the Hyper Bowl when I said many months ago that Trumble would get to the point that the Coalition would get a bounce by going back to Abbott.

    2014 is going to feel like the good old days for these scumbags.

  17. Zoomster – I’m not sure there was much he could do until the decision was finally handed down. But you’re assuming that Malcolm DOES planning. Like I said, he’s a conman. He sells you a bag of shit and, while your rummaging around to see what you’ve got, he’s moved onto his next con. He doesn’t do implementation. There is no after-sales service. It’s all smoke and mirrors. Seriously. I know it’s hard to grasp that someone like that is now our Prime Minister, but he is!
    I mean, look at the AWU raids fiasco. Malcolm was obviously up to his neck in that. He just saw it as a great wheeze to get him through the day. Hollow as a drum.

  18. For dtt….the US is a net oil exporter once again. I doubt US producers will accept Yuan for their products unless they carry a warrant that assures they can be converted into something else….

    In 2016, total U.S. petroleum exports averaged about 5.2 MMb/d, which made the United States a net exporter (exports minus imports) of petroleum. The total U.S. petroleum exports includes about 0.5 MMb/d of crude oil, 52% of which went to Canada. Most U.S. petroleum exports are petroleum liquids and refined products.May 8, 2017

  19. ratsak @ #319 Sunday, October 29th, 2017 – 6:14 pm

    Some folks thought I was using the Hyper Bowl when I said many months ago that Trumble would get to the point that the Coalition would get a bounce by going back to Abbott.

    2014 is going to feel like the good old days for these scumbags.

    I have been cheering for Abbott for ages, expecting him to make things worse… but now that you mention it 🙂

    Surely, barring the odd crap sample, the next round of polls will finally get to 55-45?

  20. Zoom and Anton,

    I don’t think Mal does planning. He had years before getting the top job and then did a few selfie walks among the people and got rid of knights and dames. It was surprising how little Mr. Innovation wanted to do. “Continuity with Change” (LOLZ). What change?

  21. Summary of commercial radio 6pm news :

    Brandis: The solicitor-general said we had nothing to worry about.

    Burke: I don’t believe you. Show us the s-g’s written opinion.

    Barnaby: I saved the taxpayers a motza by not resigning earlier, it would have been money wasted if the HC had found me innocent.

  22. And I thought the right liked a ‘black letter’, interpretation of our constitution and other laws passed by parliament

    “In an interview on Sky News on Sunday the attorney general said the government accepts and respects the court’s decision to disqualify deputy prime minister Barnaby Joyce and four senators but accused it of preferring a “strictly literalist” reading of the constitution rather than deciding based on its purpose.”

  23. Does anyone remember that typing training ad?

    You know, the one where the person praising it says: wtte (in the most wooden, soulless version, rabbit-in-the-spotlight cat-got-your-tongue-fear): And. They’re. So. Good. They. Do. It. For. People. Like. Me. (Like she’s a complete fucking idiot).

    We didn’t get to find out if she got the job.

    But her likesake, 50 years later, did get a job.

    Meet Michaelia Cash. Different day, same idiot.

    Why does the current LNP think she’s a star? “vomit fingers”

    Shes’s awful.

    Is that really the best they can do, in the femme stakes?

    She can’t even speak properly. Unless it’s this over-exaggerated rabbit-in-the-spotlight speak from the above-mentioned ad.

    And Devine and Co thinks she’s a Super Woman? Fuck me, I though Devine had a little more self-respect.

    Just goes to show they’d sell their soul to be paid by the devil.

  24. John Reidy

    And I thought the right liked a ‘black letter’, interpretation of our constitution and other laws passed by parliament

    Hilarious when you consider how many years they have spent bitching about “activist judges” .

  25. I think an apparent lack of planning by Turnbull was shown by his walking out after one question.

    As I said at the time, gutless!!!!

  26. Barnaby: I saved the taxpayers a motza by not resigning earlier, it would have been money wasted if the HC had found me innocent.

    The news grabs I’ve heard today have had Barnaby lamenting that he DIDN’T resign when it first came to light he had dual citizenship.

    Seems there’s something for everyone in tonight’s news! 😀

  27. kezza:

    There’s only one reason Cash is on the front bench: she’s a woman and because the coalition have a woman problem they need to promote the likes of her to show that they aren’t just a party of old white men.

    If Cash is the face of the coalition’s women then they may as well revert to the Howard standards of leaving women languishing on the backbench, aka ‘Howard’s pot plants’ as a former PBer used to refer to them.

  28. JR

    but accused it of preferring a “strictly literalist” reading of the constitution rather than deciding based on its purpose.”

    Poor old George …

    There is nothing ‘literalist’ about it.

    The intention is clear as is the language.

    If you don’t ‘like’ the way it works put up a referendum proposal.

  29. ‘fess

    Gee, all this criticism of Cash, poor woman.

    She’s the quintessential Australian woman you see every day, … or maybe not.

  30. News coverage have been very negative for the government. There is a sense of chaos and perception that the government is a mess. Labor attack lines are easy hits and government has lost control of the narrative.

  31. There’s not much more than 75 weeks until we have to go to an election for the senate. There are 75 Coalition MHRs. They really should just say fuck it, let’s all have a week as PM. Draw a name out of a hat each Sunday and then pop down to visit General Pete.

    It’s a win-win-win plan

    The country wins because Trumble isn’t PM any more and with only a week in the job each new dope would really have to excel to fuck up the week as much as Trumble would.

    Each Coalition MHR wins as they all get to achieve the top job they all crave but none have the ability to perform.

    And even Trumble potentially wins. It’s a long shot, but with some of the freaks in the Coalition one or two of them might even prove bad enough in 7 days to take over the mantle of the Country’s worst PM from him.

  32. Confessions @ #342 Sunday, October 29th, 2017 – 6:46 pm

    kezza:

    There’s only one reason Cash is on the front bench: she’s a woman and because the coalition have a woman problem they need to promote the likes of her to show that they aren’t just a party of old white men.

    If Cash is the face of the coalition’s women then they may as well revert to the Howard standards of leaving women languishing on the backbench, aka ‘Howard’s pot plants’ as a former PBer used to refer to them.

    Sure, the LNP has a problem with women. Goes without saying.

    But to let loose Michaelia Cash, pfft that’s something else.

    Can you imagine, just for a minute, hang on, you’d have to imagine for about 30 minutes, Miranda Devine and Michaelia Cash in the same room.

    Not one woman I know would give Cash the time of day, if she tried the old “speaking like an idiot moron” for more than a minute. She’d get howled down for hogging the limelight with nothing to say.

    And the right wingers want to tell us she’s Super Woman!

    Jesus Halleluyah Christ. Miranda Devine would eat a woman like that for breakfast. Guess she’s a bit overwhelmed by Madam Spanky Prefect ex-Abbott pull-stringer, that wholesome Peta Credlin Nonsense.

  33. CTar:

    Quintessential Australian everyday woman or not, Cash has demonstrated repeatedly she is not up to the job of Minister.

Comments Page 7 of 9
1 … 6 7 8 9

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *