Another bad Newspoll this week has kept the pressure on Tony Abbott, but the latest reading of the BludgerTrack poll aggregate has taken some of the edge off the formidable lead Labor opened up last week, thanks to softer results from Roy Morgan and Essential Research. The 0.7% shift on two-party preferred results in five seats changing hands on the seat projection, including one in every state except Western Australia. Despite that, the leadership ratings record further improvement for Bill Shorten, since Newspoll is the only one of the three to have provided a new result. Shorten has now opened up a small but clear lead over Tony Abbott as preferred prime minister, and there has been a solid uptick in his net approval rating while Tony Abbott continues to flounder.
Further:
Keep an eye on this post for all your Canning by-election news needs, including a fresh batch of snippets posted just now, and a fairly intensive account of yesterday’s slightly perplexing ReachTEL result.
Tasmanian Labor Senator Lisa Singh has been dumped to a theoretically unwinnable fourth position on the party’s Senate ticket, behind incumbents Anne Urquhart of the Left and Helen Polley of the Right, and most contentiously non-incumbent John Short, state secretary of the Left faction Australian Manufacturing Workers Union, who is set to take third place. The elevation of Short ahead of a factionally unaligned woman front-bencher (Singh is shadow parliamentary secretary for the environment, climate change and water) has not been well-received, but Bill Shorten says he will not seek to have the decision overturned by the party’s national executive. It’s worth noting, albeit just barely, that Tasmania is the state where it is least implausible that below-the-line voters might trump the order of the party-mandated Senate ticket, owing to the smaller number of candidates and voters’ familiarity with choosing between party candidates under the Hare-Clark system in state elections. This was known to happen in Tasmania in the decade after the present Senate electoral system was introduced in 1949, but it hasn’t come anywhere near occurring since the above-the-line voting option was introduced in 1984. The below-the-line voting rate was 10.34% in Tasmania at the 2013 election, compared with 3.51% nationally.
The Greens in South Australia have suffered the embarrassment of having candidate interview reports for its Senate preselection leaked to the media. The contents suggest that the front-runner for a preselection to be determined on September 6 is Robert Simms, an Adelaide City councillor who was rated as highly recommended owing to a combination of experience, vision and political skills. Bension Siebert of InDaily reports that the remaining contenders were ranked into two categories, the more flattering of which was headed competent. This included former Greens state parliamentary candidate Matthew Carey, state Hindmarsh Greens branch convenor Rebecca Galdies, and former federal Greens candidate and environmental lawyer Ruth Beach. Then came needs further development, which applied to Sam Taylor, media adviser to state upper house MP Mark Parnell, and Adelaide Hills councillor Lynton Vonow. The report was the work of a panel including Mark Parnell and three other figures in the state party.
Tom Richardson of InDaily reports that Jo Chapley, in-house legal counsel for Foodland supermarkets, has firmed as a Labor frontrunner to take on Christopher Pyne in Sturt. However, the report also says that other party figures are reluctant to push her for the Sturt pre-selection unless they can guarantee a lavish warchest from Labor’s national head office to run a genuine marginal-seat-style campaign.
Steve Georganas has been confirmed as Labor candidate for the Adelaide seat of Hindmarsh, which he held from 2004 until his defeat at the hands of current Liberal member Matt Williams in 2013, after the withdrawal of his sole preselection rival, Delia Brennan.
My recent paywalled contributions to Crikey offer an account of the recent recovery in Bill Shorten’s personal ratings, and early impressions of the Western Australian federal redistribution (despite what the headline says).
@FarrellPF: Transfield profits drop as shareholders sell over asylum abuse on Nauru, Manus http://t.co/pUAhiRL3T0
Guytaur
The media are the perennial scapegoat for bad politicians. Both sides blame them rather than accepting they have stuffed up.
guytaur
Hooray! The tectonic plates are shifting at last.
Diog
Surely you can’t deny that the media have played Abbott’s game for years in order to create ‘the most brilliant opposition leader’.
While I don’t want to spark another round of Rudd v Gillard supporters infighting:
And what of Rudd’s ‘cardinals’ … what debt do we owe them for their concerted effort to undermine a government that could have worked had it been united? How much did their actions deliver us this idiot PM?
None of it can be quantified with simplicity.
We have all the personalities and (at best) a somnambulist media …. am being VERY kind there. A potent soup that meant the loudest and most strident voice got the bikkies.
Diogenes
You are wrong. The media were acting like rabid dogs with their bias.
This is the truth. They put Abbott on a pedestal and magnified every fault of Gillard then Rudd.
Remember no matter what you think of her Gillard did not lose an election. She won against the odds. While I think she would have lost the election see media coverage we will never know as the party replaced her with Rudd.
Both sides have elements of the media against them.
All politicians get undermined by their own side. Just look at Abbott at the moment.
These are weak excuses, just like rabid sports supporters blaming the umpire.
Diogenes
You have a short memory. Photoshop front pages of Murdoch Press.
Murdoch’s press has a proven history. An organisation that has even stooped to stealing a missing child’s phone messages to get more sales. We are not talking a fair ethical moral organisation here.
I am with Dio. Fairfax are giving the current government as much stick as News gave the Gillard government. The current government probably deserves it a bit more though.
DWH
Where has Fairfax photoshopped Abbott as a Nazi character from a tv series?
guytaur I agree News does more colourful front pages than Fairfax but that’s just one small part of the coverage.
All the pro- and anti- Julia stuff here (I’m pro by the way, but I do recognize that she made some mistakes) reminds me of the time a pair of our local Labor activists wrote a letter to the local rag complaining about the railways parking trains opposite their house with motors running and lights on half the night. Next issue, there’s a letter attacking the complainants with all sorts of irrelevant rubbish about their wide-spreading trees. I asked one of them whether the second letter-writer was a “Liberal” (as they call themselves). She said “No, a member of the opposing faction in the local ALP branch.”
This dialogue seems to be the same, as far as I can gather. Just f’ing stop it, you factional warriors, and fight the real enemy!
BTW, I have some sympathy for Julia over SSM. Like her, a couple of years ago I thought “why aren’t they satisifed with civil unions (and why can’t heteros have that as well?)?” But I’ve come to see that real equality demands that we recognise everyone’s right to the thing called marriage. Came to it a bit quicker than her, though, but I still don’t aligning with the Julia-bashers.
dio
I am not referring to you. you are discussing PMJG’s performance as PM. I do not agree with you, but respect your right to that opinion. You may be right, or I might be. But you are respectful.
dwh
No thats the front page that also goes on advertising banners. Thats no small part. Thats the main game during an election campaign. Make no mistake at the aim of these attacks.
They are biased poisonous bile.
Reality is not photoshopped
This from the Government Gazette. I suspect we are being set up for the inevitable tomorrow, something like – Bad Unions, Good Man Dyson, Labor Party grubby tactics defending their union mates
*don’t align*! Ahhh, stupid fingersw!
From Daniel Andrews via facebook —
Dio
The media was Abbott’s extra man on the pitch. They even made up stuff about her. And when are we going to see Tony and Margie rooting under the Aussie flag, in At Home With Tony?
Am not sure that third place on the ALP Senate ticket in Tasmania is any better than “winnable”, definitely no certainty for the person in question. But, following the Pratt/Bullock fiasco, a terrible look for the party.
That’s some quality leadership from Dan Andrews.
Simply not true. Abbott is undermining himself, creating a free for all. I have never seen such poor leadership in any other PM. Hawke and Howard were both stalked by Treasurers who believed it was their turn to be PM. Fraser was at the very end of his PM-ship. Keating suffered more from poor choices in ministers and a degree of hubris. Rudd – well people have their fixed ideas and I’m not in the mood to comment a the moment. But at least until the end of 2009 he had his whole team demonstrably united behind him – and that is unarguable fact.
Abbott is a total bag of insubstantial chaos. What you are seeing from his ministers and backbench is not undermining but utter frustration (Turnbull aside – and he is more making a play for public affection than actually undermining Abbott).
guytaur
Actually, no.
Firstly, I’m not aware of his support for ME. He famously told Kerryn Phelps he was going to support it and then voted against.
Secondly, ME was not discussed at the National Conference when he was leader because he didn’t want it to be.
Guytaur
Probably best not to rehash the Julia thing but it is good that you can accept that at times she made some bad judgement calls. This is good, because it signals a chance to analyse just what these were, why they were bad and what lessons can be leaned. In other words analyse the actions of the PM in terms of judgement and impact, without reference to sex or personality or the R word.
Since it is always “the economy stupid” I nominate latching on so hard to the surplus as a bad judgement call because it was risky and because many, many voices said it was silly. Aiming for a surplus is good, but hitching government credibility to the surplus wagon was not a good judgement call. Of course there is NO comparison to the absolute complete and incomprehensible lack of judgement of Abbott and Hockey in 2014, but I was comparing it to actions taken by normal human beings not chimpanzees.
Sorry for any slight to chimpanzees
FFS Dio.
There was a non stop daily sexist and misogynist attack on Gillard for years that descended to the lowest levels and became the standard media narrative.
I have posted here in the past 20-30 examples of such emanating just from leading Liberal politicians – to list those from the media would takes several pages.
As a woman, and on no other criteria, Gillard was daily blasted in the media for such crimes of judgement as :
having an empty fruit bowl
having a big bum
having breasts
having red hair
having a strange accent
wearing glasses without permission
wearing dresses that failed to meet statutory requirement
having no dress sense
knitting
being barren
being unmarried
being an atheist
noting blue ties
touching Obama
telling the Europeans they could do better when she didn’t tell them
Having a ‘strident’ tone
speaking down to people
being a poor public speaker
failing to answer answered questions
starting the misogyny wars after only being the target for hundreds of misogynistic barbs over several years
…
See what I mean about ‘pages’ in the list?
Even the above is tip of the iceberg.
I have also noted here previously an open letter that strongly criticised the trend noted above as a new and dangerous tactic in political rhetoric.
That was written before the misogyny wars erupted and was signed and supported by over 140 Australian organisations involved in sexual assault, domestic violence eradication and the like
.
To repeat the media meme that the campaign against that woman Gillard was ‘normal’ politics is simply to blindly buy the sexist and media narrative of the MSM and the far right.
zoomster
Mr Rudd never had to make a decision about a conscience vote being voted on a private members bill as far as I am aware.
Mr Shorten and Mr Entsch’s are the first I am aware of.
As for National Conference you are correct and that is where Gillard is better for the issue than Mr Rudd. However a lot of that is to do with the passage of time and how learning of the issues changes peoples minds.
I think that Rudd passively not actively blocked. However Mr Abbott is actively blocking his members from having a free vote in parliament of that there is no doubt.
DTT
I agree on the surplus thing. I don’t know why the spin doctors and politicians in the Labor party thought that was a good idea in any way.
Plan for the worst hope for the best should have been the thinking.
guytaur
No, but when he was given an opportunity to vote on the issue, he voted no. I am unaware that his position has changed.
Apparently it was OK for Rudd to vote no but it’s outrageous Gillard did (I know that’s not your position).
Meanwhile, back in the REAL World of 2GB…
Hot topics all this morning have been:
Some Muslim guy who wouldn’t stand up for a magistrate
He’s a “moron”, a “dope” and “should be sent off back to wherever he came from (he was born in Australia).
On and on they’ve gone on about this guy. Ben Fordham yesterday, all afternoon, Chris Smith (filling in for Alan Jones) this morning and, of course, Hadley after Smith.
This also allowed Hadley to get onto his pet hobby horse of “the absolute, gutless idiots who run Corrective Services in NSW”. The latest Head of Corrective Services has, for some reason, incurred Hadley’s ire, and copped both barrels for allowing this Muslim man to not only sit down while in Court, but did not press him to kneel when he was having the cuffs put on him prior to a Court appearance. He stopped short of calling for the reintroduction of the rubber hose to beat prisoners up, but he was heading that way.
Hadley also bragged that the Daily Telegraph had taken up the story, first broken on Hadley’s show yesterday by a listener who had been in the courtroom at the time.
Julia Gillard’s Change Of Mind on SSM
A “complete dope” according to Hadley. A “devious, two-faced back-stabber” as well. “We did good to get rid of THIS WOMAN” according to both Hadley and several of his listeners. A “liar”, “bullshit artist” etc. etc. “Poufs – that’s what they really are, Ray – will be forcing people to marry their pet dogs if we don’t watch out.”
Recurring theme throughout the morning.
Tim Flannery
Warragamba Dam is spilling, therefore Global Warming doesn’t exist. What a “cretin”, “myth maker”, “panic merchant” etc. Flannery is. They really HATE Tim Flannery.
Joe Hockey on a Republic
Joe has upset Tony Abbott, therefore he has upset Ray Hadley, therefore he has upset Hadley’s listeners. Joe “ought to pull his head in”, stop “faffing about with irrelevant matters”, “run the country instead of run for office” (PM’s office, presumably, on the back of the Republic?). Listeners fathers “died for that flag” and Joe and Fitzy should “be ashamed of themselves”.
Joe should also cease associating with Peter Fitzsimmons, who is a well known “far left” critic of Tony Abbott (according to Smith and Hadley), and “give up this ‘Republic’ rubbish for the lost cause it is”. Hockey and Fitzsimmons have been mates for decades.
Hadley had Mr Potato Head on, who stopped short of agreeing that Joe should go for embarrassing Tony Abbott, but who did reveal that he had had “a word with Joe” last night on the phone. Also agreed that Fitzsimmons is a “radical lefty”, typical of those who would saddle Tony Abbott with Labor’s debt and deficit disaster. Mr Potato Head also bragged that he had ejected an asylum seeker from critical mental health care which was “costing the taxpayers of Australia millions of dollars”. Hadley quipped that the man cannot be insane because he was smart enough to come to Australia “the greatest country God put on Earth.”
Callers… “Hear, Hear, Ray!”.
(I wondered to myself how many of Hadley’s listeners have written large, in-depth researched best-selling books on BOTH Kokoda and Gallipoli, as Fitzsimmons has).
Desalination Plants
(A segue from discussion of Tim Flannery on Chris Smith’s segment)… Politicians who built desal plants “oughta be hanged” for all the schools and hospitals they could have built with the wasted money on desalination plants. – Smith’s words.
Lucky someone at the ABC didn’t say that, or else Border Farce would have been after them and their citizenship.
An ad for UBD Street directories
This ad was on Hadley’s show yesterday, and it urged listeners to purchase a book-version UBD street directory for Father’s Day, using the slogan “Tell Dad to get it hard” (meaning “hard copy”, but with an obvious double entendre).
Hadley had the ad banned from future broadcast, and lambasted the advertising agancy “dopey mongreals” who would sully his fine, family show with such smut. One “Roxy” an account manager at the ad agency had commented on a blog that she didn’t think Hadley – “just an announcer” – had the power to ban an ad that had been booked for air time and paid for. Which of course got Hadley’s gander up. He whipped himself into a state of high dudgeon that anyone could be so “pathetic” and “stupid” not to know that HADLEY TOLD 2gb WHAT ADS THEY COULD RUN, NOT THE OTHER WAY AROUND, ESPECIALLY AFTER “90 SUCCESSIVE RATINGS WINS
Hadley told 2GB what ads they could run, not the other way around, especially after he had delivered “90 successive ratings wins” in the time slot for the station. He was just aboout spitting with venom at the end of his 30 second diatribe, really worked-up and shouting at anyone who did not know that Ray was King.
So the Big Issues are not the economy, or going to war, or the disastrous, rudderless management of Australia. They are:
* Muslims who won’t stand up before magistrates,
* Desalination plants,
* Joe Hockey’s Republic whimsy,
* Tim “Foolery” Flannery, a clown extraordinaire,
* Peter Fitzsimmons,
* Desalination plants,
* The myth of Global Warming,
* Corrective Services mismanagement,
* The wonderful Daily Telegraph,
* UBD street directories and the “idiots” at advertising agencies who patronize 2GB, but dare to criticise Hadley.
and of course,
* “That woman”: Julia Gillard.
Those of youse who think other matters are more important are deluding yourselves.
guytaur at 176
Please see this article:
http://www.abc.net.au/news/2012-09-19/same-sex-marriage-bill-voted-down/4270016
You will notice that Mr Rudd is listed among those voting ‘no’.
zoomster
Yes double standards are indeed there. Mr Rudd during election campaign declared his support for ME before Abbott won.
Its only the length of time that is different on this issue for Rudd and Gillard. Both are now in the same position and I think that says a lot for Labor rather than a detriment.
Sustainable future @ 111
This is a question that should be posed to Andrew Hastie if anyone has the guts.
a new theme for labor to pursue? – “Everything Mr Abbott does is about playing politics. everything Mr Abbott does is about saving his skin. Everything Mr abbott does is about short-term political advantage and NOTHNG about good governance and planning for a fair and sustainable future for Australia.”
Shea McDuff…
You missed:
* having “shankles” (i.e. fat ankles).
… a big favourite of Ben “Mate, Mate” Fordham on 2GB and his Tradie listeners.
Don’t know how much real influence the discredited ABC has these days, but it was never as terrified of offending the previous government as they are with this one. Indeed quite the opposite. Who can forget the seemingly never ending news bulletins beginning with ‘the opposition says…’?
They are still buying every pathetic Abbott stunt, hook line and sinker, whereas were it Gillard or Labor we’d have the predictable snearing tone.
I think Rudd was LOTO when the stem cell conscience vote happened. Both sides had a conscience vote, and both leaders opposed stem cells but, fortunately, stem cells got up.
My final say on JG.
She made some bad calls…. probably worst one was “I don’t care if you call it a tax or not”. Another bad one “games on” to Abbott after becoming PM. She had no idea that he has no bottom moral line in attack.
She was not patronising as Diogenes claims. It is inconsistent with being an A1 negotiator (as affirmed by Windsor et al and many others) to have a patronising orientation. Ditto re holding a fragile minority government together full term.
She was endlessly shafted by the media exemplified most by “At Home with Julia” ( if that’s what it was called).
I was proud to have a lady PM and to have her personally. In “normal” times she’d have had at least two terms and got lots done.
History will treat her quite OK.
All IMHO.
@TBA77 – People on the left aren’t objecting to the idea of letting the people decide.
The objections are that:
A) The people have decided. Point to a single time in the history of polling that so many reputable polls have pointed to 65-70% support for a thing, and the actual result in a free and fair election was less than 50%. Having a people’s vote is expensive and pointless.
B) The timing. This is a simple change. The vote could be held in a few weeks, or at the next election. To delay it to some time in the future is just delaying tactics in the hope that it will blow over.
C) Making it a referendum instead of a plebiscite even though the constitution is irrelevant, simply because this slightly reduces the chances of it occurring.
Ahh, Shea, you’ve reminded me of Julia’s voice. It changed when she became PM. Before, she had always been nasal but it had been lively – she had absolutely dominated the House at times. As PM it became flattened and recitative. Just possibly it was a desire to seem under control now she was PM, but I rather suspect it was coaching by the media minders. In my former employment I attended a course (half-day or a day) in media relations where they tried to coach us into losing all spontanteity and staying on the corporate message. A couple of months later they offered an advanced course. I said no very firmly. My advice to all pollies is take a bit of voice coaching (to improve projection not to increase poshness) but shun, avoid, and abjure any media-relations coaching. Just be yerselves! (That seems to be why Jeremy Corbin is so popular in Inng’land – ‘e’s ‘imself.)
I agree that At Home with Julia was diabolical from a state broadcaster.
In general, and William can explain this a lot more authoritatively than I, the voters gravitate to a media product which reinforces their beliefs. If the media product disagrees with their beliefs, they find numerous ways of dismissing the report rather than changing their opinion.
The media has a lot less influence than they lead us to believe.
Kiera @KieraGorden 14h14 hours ago
Tony grooms his replacement. LOL #AusPol via @DunkenKBliths
Puff, the Magic Dragon.@148
Puffy,
Just because someone recognises the incompetence of a particular woman in a particular position does not make them a misogynist and I resent your continuing accusations against myself and others.
Puff, the Magic Dragon.@150
This is just absurd and unworthy of you.
You can be patronising to the public and negoatiate well with your peers.
BB@179:
Yep. The Toady’s Tory Toddlers are getting that shrill note that presages a full blown, heel-drumming, high-pitched, I-hate-you-mummy, middle-of-the-express-aisle tantrum. Has anyone seen True Idiot post when Hadley is on air?
I have very few positive things to say about Kevin Rudd as he was from the beginning of 2010 onwards. I have been quiet mostly for fear of unleashing the Gillard hating cultists.
It has occurred to me, though, that it is not enough to be silent on the unremitting acts of betrayal of Rudd and his closest cronies from the moment he unleashed his zipful of tears on an unsuspecting nation. Saying anything positive about Julia Gillard is enough to unleash the howls of the Rudd-flavoured Kool-aid drinkers.
I just want to make one point in response to a ridiculous furphy that has been abroad since I’ve been on this board and probably for a long time before.
Apart from a media that signally failed to achieve even the lowest rungs of professional competence for 4 years, the Coalition members who threw whatever decency overboard in their eagerness to ride the Abbott sickness to power, and the Australian people who decided to give Abbott a chance despite his patent unfitness to be PM, there is one other group that is as responsible as anyone for giving us Abbott.
And that group, ably represented on this board, are those people for whom righting the ‘wrong’ of June 2010 mattered more than anything else. Those people who, despite being nominally Labor, even members of the Parliamentary Party, would rather undermine Labor during an election campaign – something I have never before – than seek victory.
And after delivering a hung Parliament, they did everything possible to make it as difficult as possible for Labor to win the next election, until the rightful king, like one of Talleyrand’s Bourbons, had been restored to the throne. They are the people who gave us Abbott. Rudd, his cronies and his apologists who chose disloyalty to Julia Gillard over loyalty to their party and their colleagues and the people who desperately did not need Abbott as PM and the Coalition in government.
So, sorry Dio. It was not dumping Rudd in 2010 that was what gave us Abbott in 2013. It was the prioritisation of getting revenge by and for Rudd that did it.
http://www.smh.com.au/nsw/i-am-normal-my-kids-are-normal-penny-sharpes-emotional-response-to-gayby-baby-furore-20150826-gj8qeg.html
Worth a read!
Bushfire
Actually I missed dozens/hundreds of similar examples and omitted some of the really big ones
most notably the cirus about the -alleged- decades old bathroom renovation which was such a successful media slur the tried to repeat it with Bill.
But thanks for that extra one, a new addition, I’d like to add it to my list but is it possible to get a cite in print/pixels not sound or vision?
BB
Sadly, I have been unable to enjoy Ray Hadley in recent times due to work commitments. However your blow by blow description brings fond memories flooding back.
Ray is everyone’s mate and the voice of reason. Unless you cross him.
zoomster@167
Andrews continues to impress me.
I didn’t have particularly high expectations when he became LOTO, but he has continued to perform way beyond my original expectations.
Dio
I am on your side.